AT&T vs Verizon: Big Red takes the lead, but which is right for you?

These days there are really only three major postpaid carriers, Verizon, AT&T, and T-Mobile. In this guide we take a closer look at two of them: Big Blue vs Big Red. You may be struggling to choose one over the other, so we’re going to pit AT&T vs Verizon to help you out.

It’s not enough to look at plans, prices, or simply a selection of phones. We’re going to go category by category and get to the heart of each carrier. Let’s start by taking a look at a quick table that breaks down their key specs:

AT&T vs Verizon — Pricing and Value

• Winner: Verizon

Historically Verizon has been the most expensive carrier, but that’s less true anymore. In fact, AT&T is more expensive these days with its Start plan starting at $65 vs Welcome’s starting price of $60. You’ll find an even bigger gap between Unlimited Extra and myPlan Unlimited Plus, with the latter priced at $10 less. Lastly, we have AT&T’s Unlimited Premium vs myPlan Unlimited Ultimate, with the former also priced $10 higher than Verizon’s offering.

Let’s break down what you actually get and see how it compares:

• AT&T Unlimited Starter vs Verizon myPlan Unlimited Welcome: Both offer LTE and 5G access without a hotspot option. You also get similar international perks. Verizon also allows you to add a few extra perks for $10 each, which we’ll talk about a bit more later.
• AT&T Unlimited Extra vs Verizon myPlan Unlimited Plus: Again we have the same LTE/5G access but the Verizon option gives you double the hotspot access at 30GB. Again it also has the ability to add perks for $10 a piece.
• AT&T Unlimited Premium vs Verizon myPlan Unlimited Ultimate: Comparing the big boys we once again see a lot of the same trends. Verizon once again doubles data over AT&T offering a whopping 60GB of hotspot access. There’s the same $10-each perks. But this time Verizon also is giving you 10GB of high-speed international data, something AT&T just can’t match.

At the end of the day it’s clear who is the better value and price here and, surprisingly, it’s Verizon. AT&T has really fallen behind the other major carriers recently and for the first time in a while we find ourselves praising Big Red.

AT&T vs Verizon — Coverage and speed

• Winner: Tie

Both carriers can claim to have the most extensive coverage area in the United States — but it depends on what network you’re looking for. AT&T boasted the largest 3G network, though it’s been retired in favor of wide-reaching 4G LTE coverage. Verizon, on the other hand, has had a lead in 4G LTE for a number of years. Both are still important for customers who live outside of major cities, though there are now faster options for some users.

If you turn your attention to each carrier’s 5G access, you’ll find that speed and availability are once again the name of the game. Verizon employs a high-speed mmWave network for its high-end 5G coverage, which is lightning-fast but offers a limited range. Big Red now has a more accessible Nationwide 5G network to fill in the gaps, too. AT&T, on the other hand, relies mainly on a low-band network that stretches across far more of the country, even if it doesn’t reach the same speeds.

You have a look at AT&T’s coverage map above and immediately see where its 4G LTE and 5G access are available, but it’s a bit trickier with Verizon. You’ll have to get up close and personal with street-by-street maps if you want the fastest mmWave coverage. However, you can see Verizon’s new Nationwide 5G network right here.

Depending on where you live, AT&T might be a better fit. It’s also typically less congested in most states and more consistent. That said for the majority of users Verizon is going to be the better option when it comes to speed and coverage. Part of me thinks I should give the win to Verizon but I’ll be diplomatic here and call it a tie.

AT&T vs Verizon — Perks and promotions

• Winner: Verizon

Neither AT&T nor Verizon offer any major perks by default, though AT&T’s Premium tier does give you HD streaming versus the 480p that Verizon defaults to for most of its plans. However, Verizon does allow you to upgrade to HD for an additional $5 a month.

While Verizon doesn’t include perks, it does offer them for just $10 each. The total list of optional Verizon are:

• Disney Bundle (Hulu, Disney Plus, ESPN Plus)
• 2TB Cloud Storage
• 100GB Mobile hotspot
• Walmart+ Membership
• Apple One
• Apple Music Family
• Smartwatch Data
• 3 TravelPass Days

AT&T doesn’t have any perks at all, optional or otherwise. It used to offer HBO Max but that’s no longer the case. Verizon’s highest tier Ultimate plan also offers one of the best international perks of any major carrier with Google Fi Wireless the only carrier that upstages it.

Both carriers offer a pretty solid selection of promos, though you’ll mainly be saving on new devices rather than plans. For more on deals, check out our guides to the best Verizon deals and best AT&T deals.

At the end of the day Verizon offers more. Heck, you can add a perk to its Plus and Ultimate plans and still end up paying the same as AT&T’s perkless alternatives.

AT&T vs Verizon — Phone selection

• Winner: Tie

Carrier-exclusive phones aren’t what they once were. Many of the leading US carriers offer nearly identical lists of devices, and sometimes the only difference is whether the phone relies on GSM or CDMA. AT&T and Verizon are no exceptions to this rule, but Big Red exclusively offers a good variety of Motorola phones, like the folding Razr.

As we mentioned before, the GSM and CDMA divide is one of the main differences between AT&T and Verizon. Big Red falls on the CDMA side while AT&T holds down the GSM camp. GSM is the newer technology, and it’s more common than CDMA, which can be great if you travel abroad often.

You can see Verizon’s full list of phones on their website, and the same goes for AT&T.

AT&T vs Verizon: Which should you choose?

• Overall Winner: Verizon

In the battle of AT&T vs Verizon it’s pretty obvious that Big Red has leaped ahead of its once very close rival. Verizon is either better or tied in almost every category that matters. That said, just because it offers a better value doesn’t mean it’s the better choice for you. AT&T has stronger coverage in certain areas as well as a wider 5G network. If you’re someone who finds themselves deep in AT&T country, Verizon’s advantages will mean nill.

Ultimately, we can’t tell you which network to pick — and maybe neither one is the right option. We highly recommend checking out our T-mobile vs Verizon and AT&T vs T-Mobile guides for an even deeper look. Not interested in the big three postpaid carriers? Check out our guide to the best prepaid plans.