Affiliate links on Android Authority may earn us a commission. Learn more.
Apple's buggy HomeView launch is making Google Home look good
Nov 17, 2026 — 7:45 AM ET

- Early Apple HomeView buyers are returning their $299 smart displays due to buggy software, unreliable Siri AI, and setup failures.
- Even prominent tech reviewers have criticized the experience, describing it as beta-like.
- Apple has promised a December update to address some Siri AI shortcomings.
Apple took its time entering the smart display market, giving Google years to establish itself in kitchens, bedrooms, and living rooms. But if the first few days of the Apple HomeView are any indication, Google may have less reason to worry about its new rival than we initially thought. Some early buyers are already packing up their $299 smart displays and sending them back to Apple.
The HomeView, which went on sale on November 13, has earned plenty of praise for its hardware. Unfortunately, the software meant to bring that hardware to life is proving to be its biggest weakness. Siri AI, whose delayed arrival reportedly held up the HomeView’s launch, is struggling with the very tasks that make a smart display worth having.
On Reddit (2) and the MacRumors forums, owners describe an experience that feels more like beta testing. Siri struggles to set timers, play music, and understand basic requests. Some users report music commands being executed on their iPhones instead, while others have resorted to rebooting both their HomeView and iPhone to get timers working again.
Some early buyers are already returning their HomeView units after repeated setup failures that even Apple Support couldn’t resolve.
Returned my Homeview. It’s too small, and worse, I could never set it up. Continually got setup failures… I called Apple Support; they ran me through a bunch of things to try, and ultimately we couldn’t get it to work. Removed VPN/MDM, tried a different wifi access point, home settings, etc. I’m not going to do Apple’s QA for them. Sorry. Plus, seeing everyone’s experience with Siri made me realize i’m not willing to wait to see if this gets magically fixed.
Others praised the industrial design but plan to return theirs because of the frustrating software and onboarding experience.
It’s really a shame just how awful Apple HomeView really is. I really wanted to love it. And the industrial design is great. But the awful onboarding experience + the super frustrating software story and Siri AI just being a hot mess makes this device hard to recommend to anyone. I will be returning mine.
Even professional reviewers haven’t been spared. The Verge‘s Tom Warren says he’s ready to return his HomeView after just a few days, describing Siri AI as so buggy that it feels like he’s constantly using beta software.
I’ve had Apple’s HomeView for a few days now and I’m ready to return it. This device is so buggy, and most of that is down to Siri AI. It feels like I’m using beta software all the time, and I’m surprised Apple shipped it like this
Meanwhile, tech journalist Joanna Stern found that Siri AI could insist the HomeView didn’t have a camera, even though one was staring right at her. Apple has confirmed that a December software update will address the latter issue and let recognized users unlock doors and open garages with Siri.

For Google Home users, these complaints feel painfully familiar. We’ve documented how the transition from Google Assistant to Gemini has left some users regretting the upgrade, arguing with their smart speakers, and even wanting their money back. Google is hardly the gold standard for smart home reliability.
Still, Google has been steadily ironing out those problems. Its latest Google Home update improves Gemini’s response times for timers and alarms, makes complex smart home commands more reliable, and fixes several Nest camera issues. These are improvements to an ecosystem Apple is only beginning to compete with in the smart display space.
Apple’s December update could make life considerably easier for HomeView owners, although there’s no guarantee it’ll address every complaint. For now, Google can take some comfort in knowing that even after years of waiting, Apple’s answer to the Nest Hub hasn’t escaped the same AI growing pains. Suddenly, that aging Google smart display on your kitchen counter doesn’t look so bad.
Conversation
Read what readers said or add your take.