The biggest mobile curve ball of recent memory has got to be LG’s introduction of modular design in the LG G5. Being able to pop out the bottom of the device and slide a range of modules in to expand functionality is actually not a new idea, having appeared on electronic devices in various forms for more than 15 years. But with a history that long and a general lack of them in the world today, are modules really the way forward or a failed remnant of the past?

s7-g5-thumbSee also: Samsung Galaxy S7 vs LG G5 hands on comparison171

First, the evidence for the negative. As I see it, and I’ve already written about some of my concerns on the LG G5 modules, LG needs the G5 to be a rock-solid 2016 flagship without relying on the expanded capabilities of modular design to make it so. If the G5 is going to compete on even ground with the Galaxy S7, it needs to be able to stand on its own two feet and not rely on a funky accessories package for the win. The S7 has accessories too, but it’s the phone that everyone is judging, not the accessories.

galaxy s7 vs lg g5 quick look aa

Barriers to modular design

So while it’s fine for the LG Friends to give the G5 an edge, the core smartphone experience needs to be up to par without them. LG is definitely aware of this fact. While speaking to LG’s Dr. Ram Chan Woo recently, he admitted to me that “probably 95% of people will use the phone without having any modules.”

LG admits that “probably 95% of people will use the phone without having any modules.”

If the LG G5 can’t bring its Friends to a fight with the Galaxy S7 and even LG knows that most people won’t use them anyway, then the next big issue is cost. The G5 needs to be competitively priced against any other 2016 flagship that doesn’t have modular design. LG can’t expect 95% of people to pay more for the G5 if they have no intention of using modules.

lg g5 camera module demonstration aa-9

The next big concern is compatibility. Right now the LG G5 is the only device in the world that works with LG Friends (and “Friends of Friends”, as LG has opened up the modular design to third-party manufacturers). It’s unclear just how keen third-party manufacturers will be to jump on board the modular design train before the G5 has proven itself as a desirable device. They will need to see that there’s actually a market for more modules beyond what LG has already made.

What happens when the LG G6 arrives? Will the existing G5 modules fit or will LG refine the idea and have a new system?

And what happens when the LG G6 arrives next year? Will the existing G5 modules fit or will LG refine the idea and have a new system in place? Updating the module mechanism would upset a lot of early adopters for obvious reasons. But if LG maintains compatibility – and it really should – then the LG G6 will be the same width as the G5 and there would be no changes to headphone port or speaker placement in next year’s flagship. While that’s perfectly fine it does kind of back LG into a corner.

Why modular design hasn’t worked so far

These five concerns: standalone experience, adoption rate, price, compatibility and future-proofing should also be seen in the light of past experience. Several other devices in the past have used additional modules to expand functionality. So why didn’t they catch on? Smartphones today are surely more well-equipped to provide a solid experience – camera, gaming, battery life, storage etc – without the need for modules than some of those late 90’s modular gadgets were.

Could it be that modules as a concept are just not compatible with the rate of technological progress? Perhaps their additional cost is simply too high a barrier to overcome on the path to widespread adoption? Or the perceived complexity of modular design is just too daunting for the average consumer. Or there simply won’t be enough third-party support to make the range of accessories genuinely enticing. There might just be too many what-ifs, buts and maybes for LG’s Friends to make enough friends in the real world.

LG Friends prototypes

Why modules might work this time

But let’s move on to the evidence in the affirmative. In recent years LG has demonstrated it appreciates that standing out from the crowd is more important than actually being better. As most flagships become increasingly similar internally, the smartphone game has gradually shifted toward external flourishes like the rear-key setup, premium materials, quirky designs and increased customization.

Within this trajectory, the modular nature of the LG G5 is truly revolutionary. It not only looks different, it is radically different from anything else before it, and potentially opens up a whole new world of accessories, peripherals and enhancements for a device, without requiring an expensive upgrade. LG Friends take a smartphone and add the potential for enthusiasts of many kinds – photographers, audiophiles and battery freaks – to value-add to their investment.

lg g5 first look aa-24

I’ve long held the view that the future of smartphones will see them become less of an interface device and more of a portable battery and processing pack for a wide range of peripherals and accessories: action cams, wearables, smart clothing, wireless headphones and so on.

We’ll have smart glasses and smartwatches for receiving information, Bluetooth headphones, fitness trackers and sensors placed in strategic locations and everything will be powered by a highly portable battery and CPU pack we carry in a pocket or backpack but never need to take out. In case you missed the obvious insinuation, that is the future we are already living in.

lg g5 first look aa-27

Flashback or forward thinking?

The LG G5 simply takes that logic to the next step. Modular design takes the screen, SoC and camera of the core mobile “hub” and grants it superpowers. Need more fine-grained control over your camera? Sure. Want a huge battery pack? No problem. Want better audio quality? Done. How about tethering a VR headset or controlling a robot? The LG G5 has that covered too.

Modular design could also be used to expand the processing and graphical potential of a smartphone... to put a laptop-strength smartphone in your pocket.

It doesn’t take a genius to recognize that the modular design concept could also be used to expand the processing and graphical potential of a smartphone too. Why not create a module with an additional high-end SoC for VR and gaming that can be added onto the G5? Maybe throw in some additional RAM as well and you suddenly have a laptop-strength smartphone in your pocket.

LG-360-VR-1

Popularity contest

The biggest issue I see between the LG G5’s modular design catching on and fizzling out comes down to time. The idea needs to catch on relatively quickly if it is to survive, within a couple of years. Unfortunately, LG doesn’t command the kind of attention or follower mentality that Apple or Samsung does. Because of this it’s easy to see the module idea fizzling out if the G5 turns out to be a flop. Samsung or Apple, on the other hand, could drag an unpopular idea along for years until it finally caught on.

The best chance LG has of making modules work is if the G5 on its own is a popular success that sells well and there’s at least decent demand for modules – both to buy them and to manufacturer them. But again, modules need to be an entirely optional extra if they are to seep into the popular consciousness. It’s unlikely they will be an overnight success, so LG can’t afford to make them the defining reason to buy the G5 or any subsequent Friends-compatible phone.

A modular standard

In the best case scenario, we get through a couple of generations of modular design and Samsung decides to pick up the idea. If this happens then LG would be wise to try to formulate a universal standard that would allow it to be the founding partner in a wider market than to attempt to corner the market for itself. I’m sorry to say, but LG is unlikely to be able to create its own accessories market like Apple has done.

If modular design gets picked up, LG would be wise to try to formulate a universal module standard.

In the worst case scenario, Samsung comes up with its own proprietary module design and drowns out LG with a superior marketing budget. I’m not sure just how good LG’s patents on the whole modular design thing are, but considering the idea has been around for a while they can’t be so completely water-tight that they preclude any kind of imitation at all.

Whether we see modular design creeping into other LG phones like the high-end V series or LG’s mid-range phones will entirely depend on the popularity of the idea in the G5. We know LG is committed to the idea – with three years of design work going into the first batch of LG Friends – and LG certainly isn’t alone in thinking modules are the way forward.

project ara

The modular revolution

PC owners have been expanding core capabilities with user-switchable components for decades. Project Ara takes the modular smartphone concept to an extreme and the rise of smartphone peripherals like drones and action cameras show that “expanded capabilities” are not just limited to what the phone can do, but also to what the phone can be used to control.

Rather than simply customize your phone's software with apps, modules allow you to customize the hardware as well.

Dr. Woo told me that LG’s original vision for modular design was to break with a Jobsian smartphone understanding. That it was a way to break free of the now-familiar smartphone experience of interacting with apps on a touchscreen, that rather than simply customize your phone’s software with apps, modules allow you to customize the hardware as well.

It’s an ambitious goal and one that just might work. It is certainly in line with where the smartphone industry is going generally – towards a more accessorized and customizable experience with the phone becoming increasingly peripheral – but it faces significant barriers in terms of adoption rate, compatibility and perceived complexity. Whether LG has the legs to go the distance is impossible to say, but if LG is to win, or even have a chance of placing, modular design can’t remain a one-man race.

Do you think modular design will flourish? Where do you see smartphone design going?

  • saksham

    i predicted it and said it openly that no one will use them modules

    • RiTCHiE

      Funny you say that and have zero word to backup why. But some will like it and others dont.

  • LGG13

    LG G5 is ugly.

    swappable battery to be interesting has to be “hot swap” (without the need to turn off the smartphone).
    LG failed to think about this, you just can slide it out and slide a new in. Ok.

  • Kevin Davis

    I like lg,unfortunately very few are going to carry a fanny pack full of friends with them.The phone,to me,is ugly in some areas and too plain in others.I’m going from an lg g3 to a galaxy s7 edge,with a moto x pure in between.Waiting on delivery(thanks,Verizon).Also,an extremely poor decision to reduce battery capacity. Good luck,lg.

  • some will love it, more will not. I think its awesome, but they failed on the design of the G5. I think if they made a more attractive phone with the modules on it, we might look at it differently. I hope LG finds success….I just dont think they will.

  • mohammed uddin

    unfortunately the success of the G5 hangs on the public’s perception of the GS7 – and samsung has definitely nailed it this time round. Had LG launched the G5 last year then it may have been a different story because as sleek as the S6 looked, it was crippled, compromised and polarising for many buyers. the G5 would have stood a chance to capture sammy customers on the rebound and capture market share. last year I tried both the S6 regular and S6 edge and found I returned both because they couldn’t deliver all round. I was drawn to the G4 but it always felt like an unfinished product that was one generation too late (think tacky plastic etc.) I would have bought the G5 but as the article nails it quite clearly the phone needs to be able to stand on its own two feet and frankly with such a small battery (that needs to be augmented with the camera grip) its failed already. Price wise the G5 is also being positioned between the price point of the regular S7 and the S7 edge (well at least here in the UAE). therefore it really needs to deliver and experience or value that beats the S7 to tempt over buyers. As a stand alone product I don’t think it can do this. however LG has a reputation of sweetening buyers by throwing in accessories for first to market buyers – so if they actually included one of ‘friends’ modules, it could seriously change things. I think I would have bought the S7 Edge already as its a solid phone if it weren’t for the fact that the user experience particularly the software is just a little plain and boring whereas LG (despite making ugly GUI) are genuinely offering a new and exciting user experience. and its for this reason why I’m leaning towards the LG V10 (yes i know it has some weaknesses compared to the Note 5 / 6P etc.) as an interim device at the right price point whilst I wait to see what the G5 is actually like when launched. my tuppence on the topic – whats yours?

    • Guest

      What are the prices of G5 and S7 edge(64 GB) in the UAE?

      Btw I know this is highly unlikely but, do you know whether there will be any offer on S7 edge during Gitex (like the Gear VR they were giving out during pre orders)?

      Thanks :)

      • MoD33n

        fyi. S7 only comes in a 32GB variant. prices are:S7 – 2499AED, S7E – 2799, G5 – 2599AED (though this was unofficial from a sales rep in the LG flagship store). doubt they would give away the Gear VR as gitex promotion because it normally retails for 399AED here. having said that, and after trying it when they had the giveaway promotion on, i felt it was quite uncomfortable and hence not a product i could/would use regularly if at all, so they just might away some more away yet!

        • Guest

          Damn. Are you sure? I thought the “only 32 GB model available” was only applicable to the US.
          But I’m guessing you pre-ordered so, I’m assuming you know for sure.

          Anyways, thanks for the prompt reply.

          • MoD33n

            So gitex is done and dusted, and yes there were plenty of reasonable offers on the s7 including free VR gear headset. The G5 had just launched here for 2499aed and it comes bundled with a free extra battery and charging dock as well as a free cam plus module…. Not bad.

  • Kevin Davis

    I love the v10,I do not love the sd808.Bad past year for android in that respect(sd810/sd808).

    • MoD33n

      care to clarify whats wrong with the SD 808? most tech reviews indicate its more than adequate in real world usage even if it does suck in almost all bench mark tests. I’m interested in getting a V10 so I am genuinely interested in finding out about other’s real work usage experiences.

  • balcobomber25

    It is going to be another in a long line of smartphone fads. By this time next year there will be an article on this very site about the death of modules.

  • Well maybe. Just shouldn’t look as bad as the G5.

  • Daggett Beaver

    “Need more fine-grained control over your camera? Sure. Want a huge battery pack? No problem. Want better audio quality? Done.”

    Want all three at the same time… uh…. maybe next year.

    • EngineerGunter

      Precisely why modules won’t ever last… Eventually, they’ll just put everything in your device.

  • charlie Jason

    The inefficiency is not worth it, in my opinion.

  • So many cons to modules. You can’t use more than one at a time, you need to either leave it on all the time or bring something extra with you to swap it later, you can’t use the same cases with certain modules, etc.

    • MoD33n

      use case scenario – If i got the G5, id opt for the camera grip as well. I normally put a case on my phone as the looks don’t bother me that much. however everytime i want to use the grip, the phone would be naked without a cover which i wouldn’t be too comfortable with as its in this use case scenario that i might actually drop it and scratch it!

  • Sami Cooper

    Modules have to add enough extra functionality, at the right price. Not convinced about the camera mod but the DAC is really gonna appeal to the budding audiophile. All those kids with fancy headphones will have another thing to brag about.

  • Rick_Deckard

    I current use the LG G4 (which I will be replacing by the Samsung S7 Edge)… I don’t like the G5…. I dont like the idea of splitting the phone and accessories in modules.. Not mention, you always need to turn your phone off…. My biggest fear is that down the road the module might get broken… The G5 is an experiment just like the Edge Series introduced by Note Edge…. I gotta feeling that next year, Samsung will release only one model, the Samsung S8 Edge….

    • Dan Smith

      I bought my S6 last year because i felt like there was little point in the edge screen. With the improvements samsung made this year i now totally get the appeal of the edge and that’s why i Pre-ordered my S7 edge. there are still people out there though who dont feel they need it and think the best course of action would be to keep with two models, even though it does feel like the regular S7 got really left out this year

  • mrjayviper

    I like the idea but I seriously doubt these LG5 “friends” will also be LG6’s friends.

  • schahram

    I don’t think the modular systems would have any place in this current society, because people are used to buy something, use it for awhile, recycle, and move on to the next new thing.

  • Karly Johnston

    Who suffers advertising anymore? Get Adguard, blocking the browser is free.

  • Mike Bastable

    I think that the modules might work if priced cheap, and these initial offering are kinda boring.. Think out of the box people!… However it is essential that any New LG modulair phones use the same standard and are compatible otherwise the idea is dead.
    How about some add ons for physically keyboard, boom speaker, e-ink 2nd screen, foto printer, laptop dock…. Something new….

  • Eric Jensen Michels

    Let’s be honest, the module is a cool feature, but in my opinion was more or a side effect of adding a removable battery to a unibody Desine, then they realized that they had usb3 connection at the bottom of the phone that they could utility of other thing, aka the modules

  • MoD33n

    oh no thats such a shame. I tried out the V10 in my local stores and I found it pretty acceptable e.g. jumping between apps by hitting the shortcuts in the secondary screen. I’m not into gaming so high end performance doesn’t bother me too much and I’m aware of the relatively poor battery life. right now, I’m thinking of taking the risk and getting one.