Big-Screen Phone Or Tablet? What Android Device To Buy?

April 24, 2011
51 1 15

    Tablets are a relatively new entry to the Android ecosystem but even so, they’ve quickly become a popular gadget to have. Being always-on and always connected has made it the go-to gadget for checking email, catching up on social sites and browsing the web. On top of all that, some versions can even make and receive calls, turning them into an ideal all-in-one device. Some of the models to currently out (as of this writing) are the HTC Flyer, the newer Samsung Galaxy Tab models and the Motorola Xoom.

    Meanwhile, device makers noticed that bigger screened phones measuring 4.0 inches and up have been well-received by Android fans. Where once only a handful of large display phones were available like the HTC Desire HD and the Dell Streak, manufacturers are now keen on making their own flagship phones to enter this lucrative market segment. The Sony Ericsson XperiaArc, the Samsung Galaxy S2, Motorola Atrix and the HTC Sensation are just a few of the recently released Androids out for sale. Powerful enough to go toe-to-toe against tablets (and a few regular computers), these so-called “superphones” are powered by dual-core processors, graphics chips and impressive displays.

    In an ideal world, I’d say just buy both but our credit cards (and spouses) being the way they are, you probably can only get one. So we have to decide: should you get a big-screen phone or a tablet? Let’s break it down, shall we?

     

    1. Web Browsing

    A tablet no doubt has the greater browsing experience. With many browsers like Opera and Firefox providing an almost desktop-like experience when viewing web pages, you really can’t beat that with the smaller screen of a phone, even if it has a 4.2-inch display. And the bigger keyboard on a tablet also doesn’t hurt. Winner: Tablet

    2. Movie Watching

    It’s no contest: you need to get a tablet for this. The screen size says it all when you want to watch movies and shows on the go. It’s no HDTV but when you need a movie fix on a road trip, a tablet fares way better than a phone. Winner: Tablet

    3. Social Networking and Calls

    If you like to use social sites like Twitter, Facebook and such, tablets are nice but the handiness of a phone is better. You can easily whip it out as often as you want to tweet without getting crazy looks from the people around you. It’s also more comfortable than a tablet if you need to make or receive calls. But if you’re more comfortable resting your face against a tablet, who am I to judge? Winner: Phone

    4. Doing Real Work

    A tablet might be useful managing to-dos and doing simple tasks but for money-making, sweat-and-blood work, you need something more than even what a phone or tablet can give you. A few amazing people can blaze through the day’s work without touching a laptop or desktop but if your work requires you to create stuff like budget reports, whitepapers or blueprints, neither one of these devices will be as elegant a solution as a full-blown computer. Winner: Tie

    5. Games

    It’s been proven that the top use of tablets are for games. For gamers weaned on the console and PC, this might seem like a head scratcher but touchscreens do make very good game platforms. A lot of big names like EA and Sony know this and are starting to bring more gaming into Android. Winner: Tablet

    6. Portability

    A big-screen phone, while bulky, is still a phone and will fit most men’s pants pockets or purses for females. Grab it off the desk and off you go. Tablets though are a bit bigger so it probably needs its own case or bag if you want it to tag along. Winner: Phone

    7. Battery Life

    Phones with oversized screens are known battery guzzlers. There have been many improvements in battery tech for the newer phones, but the fact remains that the smaller body of a phone cannot house a bigger battery. In fact, many sport the same battery capacities of their smaller cousins and this paired with a gigantic screen means you need to keep a charging cable handy if you want non-stop use of your phone. On the flip side, tablets can carry juice up to 2-3 days worth with regular usage due to the bigger battery capacities that come with them. Winner: Tablet

    8. Connectivity

    Both tablets and big-screen phones carry the same type of communication chips inside: WiFi, 3G, HSDPA, Bluetooth, GSM/CDMA. So the point is moot; you can get connected either way. If you need to be always connected to the internet, both types of devices can hook you up easily. Winner: Tie

    9. Security

    We know that you live in a good neighborhood yourself but a lot of times, you need to pass through bad ones to get to where you want to go. If you’ve been accustomed to using your device on the go, chances are you’re going to whip that out whenever you need to check something online. A tablet is much more flashy in this regard and attracts the eyes of the not-so-trustworthy crowd. It’s also harder to stash and keep out of sight unless you carry a bag as well. Winner: Phone

    10. Camera Use

    I’m not talking about a better megapixel camera here. What I mean here is using the built-in camera in regular situations. You would be hard pressed to use a tablet camera for anything besides video calls due to the bulk. For phones, even big phones, you can quickly whip them out to catch the moment on video or as an image. What’s more, the faster processors often let you take shots almost instantly and give no lag when recording video. This means less fumbling and more preserving precious moments. Winner: Phone

    11. Price

    You would be surprised but price is not an issue. The price points of larger screened phones and tablets hover at around the same level. In addition, you can probably get a good tablet with 3G connectivity at the same price as a high-spec phone. For example, a Galaxy Tab fetches roughly the same price as a Google Nexus S (both brand new) over at Amazon. Winner: Tie

     

    Conclusion

    While I did put which device won on each category, there really is no clear-cut winner here between big-screen phones and tablets. Each has its merits which you should consider when planning your purchase. If you’re the social, out and about type of person who makes calls, tweets almost every hour and likes to snap everything in sight, a big-screen Android phone would be better for you. There is the issue of battery life though, but your usage probably won’t drain the battery too much (hopefully).

    On the other hand, if you’re the type that likes browsing, games and movie watching, an Android tablet is definitely what you should consider getting instead, most especially if you prefer texting versus calling. Now all you need now is to decide which tablet or phone model to get, which is another story altogether.

    Comments

    • http://www.yelp.com/biz/atlanta-roofing-resources-atlanta Atlanta Roofing

      They are very nice sleek tablets, sort of what you expect from Sony. S2 is interesting but not sure on how practical it will be as surely the dual screen approach will compromise weight to support the screen and probably performance too. But I think the issue for any tablets going in the market these days will be the OS.

    • odin

      Great piece! I learned a lot and it also help make up my mind. I’m going with the big screen phone. Thanks for your time and post.

    • Cmanus

      how bout a tablet with bluetooth headset for a phone?

      • Basileis

        That should work as good as normal phone….

        • Tim

          I hope you are paying attention HTC, samsung .Many of us only want one device to watch movies through making phone calls. and how about a strp on carrying case ect.

    • Igorcarlier

      i dont understand why make tablets with 3G for data and not also to make phone calls , one day all tablets no matter the size will be able to make phone calls.

      • Reed Rice

        There is a tablet out now that can do that

    • Pachava

      Thanks for your point wise discussion, cleared my doubts..

    • Franknboo

      Hellooooo! Why not combine the phone into the tablet? Why should I carry around two devices, just so you can make more money?
      Get it together it is not rocket science, look at the other comments!

    • Vegard Vevstad

      I’m not buying any of them until the phone is a standard feature and the screen is at least 10″; will use a Bluetooth device when phoning.

    • Tami

      Wow!! SO glad–and incredibly grateful–for this well-written article:) Having been out of the loop on electronics for awhile, I feel like a total dork for not even knowing what a Tablet is…and of course, why would you buy one instead of a phone…and all the other questions that you answered in the article. I’m also grateful for the simple language–readability is vital when you are trying to figure all this stuff out….and this is the first article I’ve come across that made any sense at all. So, good job, and thank you so much for taking the time to educate my oh, so un-informed mind!! You rock!

    • dash

      waste :-)

    • oioioi

      This is very useful. Big screens are better for movies and small phones are easier to carry around. I’ve learned a lot today :)

    • Jom

      Well seeing as a i have a laptop anyway,that can do gaming,etc,buying a 10 inch would seem redundant. I think a phone would be better for me.

    • Cutedevil00

      They are both great but .. some other tablets like cherry mobile or torque is not applicable for a long usage and charging cuz it bulge when its overcharged and stuff.. :/

    Popular

    Latest