PS5 vs PS5 Digital Edition: Which console is better for you?

After selling out for years, the PlayStation 5 is consistently in stock. If you’re considering picking one up, there’s still a choice: do you get the standard disc-capable version or the digital-only release? In this post, we’ll consider the PS5 vs PS5 Digital Edition battle on a feature-by-feature basis.

Notably, the differences outlined below apply to the refreshed PS5 Slim Digital and Disc editions, as well as the launch versions of the PS5 Digital and Disc editions.

PS5 vs PS5 Digital: What are the major differences?

While the Xbox Series S and Xbox Series X have significant performance differences, PS5 and PS5 Digital Edition specs are identical. No matter which PS5 console you choose, you’ll get the same speedy SSD, the same quality graphics, the same amount of internal storage, and more. There are really only three major differences between the consoles.

Disc drive

The most obvious difference between the two is that the standard PS5 comes with a Blu-ray disc drive while the Digital Edition doesn’t. If you’re into collecting Blu-ray and DVD movies or have a huge physical PS4 game collection, the choice is clear.

Being without a disc drive, anything you buy for the Digital Edition has to come from the PlayStation Store. Many people prefer downloads regardless, but be aware that internal storage can fill up faster, and installation will last anywhere from minutes to hours depending on the size of a game and your bandwidth.

Design

There is a slight design difference because of the presence or absence of a disc drive. The standard disc version of the PS5 has a bulge at the bottom, whereas the Digital Edition is slimmer and more symmetrical. Notably, the original “fat” PS5 with a disc drive weighs around 500 grams more than the Digital Edition. Everything else is identical, such as USB ports and height.

Price

Sony no longer sells the standard launch PS5 model, but it does sell it refurbished in the US for $399.99. The same is true for the original Digital Edition, which you can get refurbished for $349.99.

The PS5 Slim models, on the other hand, start at $449 for the Digital model and $499.99 for the Disc-toting alternative. Digital edition owners can also purchase a disc drive add-on for $79.99.

PS5 vs PS5 Digital Edition: Specs

PS5 vs PS5 Digital Edition: Which should I buy?

No matter how much you look at the debate between the standard PS5 vs the Digital Edition, both options are fantastic if you can afford them. One or the other may suit you best, however.

Should I buy the standard PS5?

If you want to collect disc copies of your favorite games, you’ll need a PS5 with a disc drive. That’s particularly true if you already have a PS4 library on disc and you’re not planning to keep the older console. Naturally, anything on disc becomes a coaster if you only have the PS5 Digital Edition.

The standard PS5’s disc drive also opens up access to movies on DVD and Blu-ray, so you can use it to play (or start) a physical collection. While that can be costly compared to a Netflix or Max subscription, the advantage is that your favorite titles won’t suddenly disappear because of rights issues or tax write-offs. Some movies have never made the transition to streaming.

Discs can also be a way around the problem of slow or flaky internet connections. Art-heavy 3D games can easily take hours to download, even on fast connections, whereas installing from a disc should only take minutes, not including shopping time. Remember that disc-based games still need to fetch updates online, even if only single-player.

The standard PS5 costs an extra $100, but the ability to shop around for the best deals and access physical media libraries is a strong selling point.

Should I buy the PS5 Digital Edition?

If you only ever buy digital copies of games, then you should probably default to the Digital Edition. It’s the cheaper of the two consoles, after all, and the PlayStation Store does have regular sales and discounts.

You’re limited to Sony’s prices, though, whatever they happen to be on a given day. Stores like Amazon, GameStop, and BestBuy may offer better deals on disc titles. That could be offset by your initial $100 savings, not to mention avoiding the cost of new shelves or bins to hold everything. Physical games aren’t immune to price hikes since they can dwindle in availability.

If you own a PS4 and bought digital copies of games on that console, you can transfer those titles to the Digital Edition. We have a guide on transferring PS4 saved data to the PS5 if you need help.

As mentioned, relying purely on downloads can fill up the PS5’s 667GB of SSD storage quickly. You’ll need to add another SSD certified by Sony to expand internal space. Follow the instructions on Sony’s website. For PS4 games, you can use an external HDD or SSD.

If you have great internet speeds and are content with only purchasing games from the PlayStation Store, the PS5 Digital Edition is a great option. Plus, you’ll have something with a more svelte design to show off.

What about the PS5 Slim?

As mentioned, Sony launched the PS5 Slim series in October 2023, giving buyers a refreshed and more compact PlayStation 5 duo. Like the original PS5 lineup, the Slim options also feature disc and disc-less Digital editions. The Digital Edition price starts at $449, with the disc-capable version starting at $499.

More intriguingly, the Digital Edition can be upgraded by purchasing and attaching an official disc drive for a further $79.99. You can buy the Digital Edition and upgrade it to a disc-accepting version later.

Ultimately, if you want a cheap PS5 console, we recommend opting for the older models if you can find them. Now that the Slim duo is available, you’ll likely find the “fat” versions for much less.

FAQs