Apple Watch vs Garmin: Which is the right platform for you?

If you’re in the market for a new wearable, you may need to make a big decision. Two industry giants, Apple and Garmin, both have a lot to offer users. While each has strengths and weaknesses, both provide a bevy of fitness tracking data, smartwatch features, and hardware options. Here’s everything you need to know when comparing the Apple Watch vs Garmin’s stable.

Apple Watch vs Garmin: Smartwatches and sport watches

The Apple Watch is one of the most influential smartwatches in existence. Apple’s wearables track your workouts, support third-party apps, and boast big, crisp displays.

Apple Watch lineup

• Apple Watch Series 8 (Amazon): Launched in early fall 2022, the Series 8 is the latest flagship wearable from Apple. It offers the same premium build and design as the Series 7 but adds crash detection and advanced health sensors we found very accurate during our Series 8 review.
• Apple Watch Series 7 (Amazon): The Apple Watch Series 7 wasn’t a huge upgrade from the Series 6, however, it ushered in a bigger display and more durability. Its performance and battery life, unfortunately, remain on par with the previous generation. We also found the Series 7’s heart rate sensor to be quite finicky.
• Apple Watch Series 6 (Amazon): Apple no longer officially sells the Series 6, but we think it’s still a worthy wearable if you can find one. The device offers great GPS and heart rate tracking, all-day battery life, and a nice display.
• Apple Watch SE 2 (Best Buy): Alongside the Apple Watch Series 8, the company also launched the second generation of its budget lineup: the Apple Watch SE 2. This device builds on the success of the Apple Watch SE with an upgraded processor and handy low-battery mode. If you can live without advanced sensors like the ECG and SpO2 monitors, it’s a solid smartwatch that will save you some money.
• Apple Watch Ultra (Amazon): A considerably more expensive device, the Apple Watch Ultra represents Apple’s first foray into the adventure market. The Apple Watch Ultra boasts the largest, most durable display in the stable, plus extra battery life and niche features for outdoor enthusiasts we loved testing during our Ultra review period.

Apple Watches don’t change much over the years, so the differences between each series are minute. The exception to this is of course the Apple Watch Ultra which is meant for a very specific set of users. In contrast, Garmin has lots of different styles of sports watches, from AMOLED-touting smartwatches to multisport fitness watches that prioritize battery life.

Garmin smartwatches and sports watches

• Garmin Venu 2 Plus (Amazon): The Garmin Venu 2 Plus is a full-fledged smartwatch. It builds on the fitness- and health-tracking features of the original Venu 2, adding on-wrist phone calls and voice assistant support. It also boasts a nice AMOLED display, on-device music storage, and FDA-approved ECG app, and support for a growing number of third-party apps.
• Garmin vivoactive 4 and 4S (Amazon): The Garmin vivoactive 4 series is getting a little old at this point but, considering there’s no vivoactive 5, we’d still recommend these devices. They’re fantastic multisport watches with built-in GPS, week-long battery life, and a number of smartwatch features.
• Garmin Venu Sq 2 (Amazon): If you’re interested in the Garmin Venu line but want something a bit cheaper, the Garmin Venu Sq 2 is a great pick. This upgrade to the Venu Sq offers an inexpensive, square smartwatch with a bright AMOLED display, accurate heart rate monitoring and GPS, and impressive battery life. We specifically suggest opting for the Music version for listening to tunes from your wrist.
• Garmin vivomove Sport (Amazon): Garmin’s vivomove series is one of its most unique and we love the vivomove Sport. This is a hybrid smartwatch with real, ticking watch hands. It also has a hidden LED display that shows notifications and stats when you need them and hides away when you’re not actively looking at the watch.
• Garmin Forerunner 55, 265, 645, 745, and 965: If you’re a runner, the Garmin Forerunner series is your best option. Ranging from budget-friendly devices like the Forerunner 55 to all-in devices like the Forerunner 965, there’s something for every runner in this lineup. We reviewed Garmin’s Forerunner 265 and were thrilled with the line’s new AMOLED display.
• Garmin Fenix 7 series (Amazon): If you’re after the most feature-packed multisport smartwatch you can buy, Garmin’s Fenix 7 series is it. These high-end watches are for serious athletes who spend most of their time outdoors. It even comes in solar models.
• Garmin Instinct 2X Solar: Outdoor enthusiasts get more than ever with the rugged Instinct 2x Solar series. A follow-up to the Garmin Instinct 2, the latest generation offers multiple color and size options, impressive battery life, and compatibility with the Garmin Connect IQ app.
• Garmin Lily (Amazon): The Garmin Lily is made for women and those generally with smaller wrists. It features a light, comfortable design, but falls a little short on features.

Apple Watch vs Garmin: Activity and health tracking

Apple and Garmin offer two of the most health-focused wearable platforms available. No matter which device you choose, you’ll be able to monitor tons of metrics and utilize a variety of activity profiles. All recent Apple Watches and Garmin watches will keep track of your steps, distance traveled, active and resting calories burned, floors climbed and elevation, intensity/active minutes, resting and active heart rate, heart rate variability (HRV), VO2 max, sleep, stress, and blood oxygen saturation.

The two platforms also offer more specialized features. Apple Watch Series 4 and up devices come with on-device ECG monitors. The company also offers detection for signs AFib and AFib History, a feature designed to provide long-term visibility into users’ heart rate activity. Apple also offers Cardio Recovery, which allows users to monitor their recovery after an outdoor walk, run, or hike, as well as track their recovery over time in the Health app.

Meanwhile, only the Garmin Venu 2 Plus offers ECG recordings at this time. Most Garmin devices will track your Body Battery, or the amount of energy you have left based on your activity level, HRV, stress, and sleeping patterns. This helps users, and particularly athletes, plan training and rest.

On the subject of sleep, Apple and Garmin also host different approaches to sleep tracking. In the past, we found Apple’s sleep tracking very basic compared to many other sleep trackers on the market. However, with the release of watchOS 9, Apple now brings deeper analysis to users’ wrists including sleep stages. Garmin watches, on the other hand, are already some of the most robust and accurate sleep trackers out there. They track users’ sleep duration, disturbances, and stages, and even provide a sleep score in the morning based on how well you slept.

As mentioned, both platforms track your resting heart rate throughout the day and night and record active heart rates during workouts. Resting heart rate is quite easy to track for most wearables, so neither platform stands out above the other in that realm. If you experience abnormally high or low heart rate readings during times of inactivity, both platforms will notify you. During exercises, both Apple Watch and Garmin devices will track your heart rate zones, as well as average and maximum heart rate. Apple’s Fitness app also gives you a nice heart rate recovery graph after you’ve finished your exercise.

In terms of heart rate sensor accuracy, we have found recent Apple Watches to be some of the most accurate wrist-based heart rate sensors you can buy — with one exception. The Apple Watch Series 7 gave us quite a few issues trying to get accurate and consistent measurements. The Apple Watch Series 8 on the other hand performed perfectly, as did the Apple Watch SE 2, and Apple Watch Ultra.

Garmin’s recent wearables also offer great heart rate tracking. Specifically, the entire current-gen Forerunner series and Fenix 7 line offer stellar heart rate data during runs and other exercises. Data from the Garmin Venu 2 Plus wasn’t as accurate, in our experience, when we reviewed the device, but we’re confident in saying the company has fixed some of the main issues with its Garmin Elevate v4 heart rate sensor. Some Garmin devices also provide a Recovery Heart Rate which measures your heart’s ability to drop back to a normal rate after a workout.

Both Apple Watch and Garmin watches also offer solid GPS tracking. Most Garmin watches are equipped with GPS, GLONASS, and Galileo, while the latest Apple Watches support GPS, Galileo, GLONASS, QZSS, and BeiDou. Accuracy between the two platforms is usually consistently high.

While you’re tracking an activity, Apple and Garmin devices can both notify emergency contacts if something goes awry. The Apple Watch offers “fall detection” which can trigger if it senses you’ve abruptly stopped. It’ll then ask you if you’d like to contact emergency services. If it senses you’re immobile for more than a minute, it’ll contact emergency services automatically.

Garmin’s incident detection works similarly. If your Garmin watch senses you fall, it’ll send your name and location to your emergency contacts. It will not, however, notify emergency services on its own. The Apple Watch Series 8 and Apple Watch Ultra also offer Crash Detection and can alert emergency services if they determine a user has been in an accident.

For those who menstruate, Apple and Garmin both offer cycle tracking. Users can log and view menstrual cycle symptoms and receive period and fertility window predictions. The Cycle Tracking app for the Apple Watch lets you log spotting and basal body temperature. The Series 8 and Ultra even feature a temperature sensor for retroactive ovulation predictions and greater period tracking accuracy. Meanwhile, in Garmin Connect, users can set reminders and receive guidance around nutrition, training, and general health.

Garmin also takes female health tracking one step further with pregnancy tracking. Users can log and view symptoms, track baby movements, and record blood glucose levels. You’ll also receive weekly feedback and advice on nutrition, fitness, and weight.

Beyond these larger health and fitness tracking features, a comparison of Apple Watch vs Garmin could go on and on. Apple Watch Series 4 and later devices can give you environmental noise notifications. Garmin offers respiration tracking. Garmin offers native hydration tracking on its watches and in Garmin Connect — there’s no need to download a third-party app to do so. Apple Watches can track your hydration via third-party apps, but not natively.

Finally, with most Garmin watches, you’ll have access to additional training features like your training status and effect, recovery time, performance condition, lactate threshold, and more. These advanced workout features are what set Garmin apart for serious athletes. As with sleep tracking, Apple recently added similar running-focused features in its watchOS 9 launch including measurements for oscillation, stride length, and ground contact time.

Apple Watch vs Garmin: Smart features

Apple Watches are smartwatches first and fitness trackers second. Even compared to the best of what the Android world has to offer (right now we’d say a Samsung Galaxy Watch), the Apple Watch provides a robust, feature-packed device, and a fluid software experience. If you want the best smartwatch features available, look no further than the Apple Watch. The Apple Watch runs apps — both first- and third-party — and uses a condensed version of the App Store for its smartwatch line. Many of the apps available on your iPhone have watchOS counterparts. You can navigate on your wrist with Apple or Google Maps, chat with friends via Messages, or stream music with Apple Music. You can also use Siri.

Seeing as how Apple makes both the iPhone and Apple Watch, connectivity between the two devices is seamless. Many of the settings on the Apple Watch mirror your phone’s settings. For example, putting your watch in DnD mode also sets your phone to silent. It’s the little things that make the Apple Watch’s software so pleasant to use. There’s one big caveat about Apple Watches, though. They’re only compatible with iPhones. If you’re already an iPhone user, great! You can continue evaluating the pros and cons of an Apple vs Garmin wearable. However, if you’re on Android and refuse to switch to iOS, Garmin is your only option. Beyond Garmin, top Apple Watch alternatives include Fitbit devices and Wear OS smartwatches.

Garmin’s operating system is one of the better RTOS-based platforms available on smartwatches, though it’s clear that the basic menus and lack of animations leave much to be desired, compared to watchOS. Garmin watches are just simpler devices overall. Garmin smartwatches also run first- and third-party apps, which can be downloaded via a separate app called Connect IQ. Most Garmin watches have support for popular music streaming services like Spotify. Due to the limitations of the RTOS software, Garmin apps tend to be simpler and more basic than Apple Watch apps. Currently, the list of Garmin watches with support for voice assistants is very limited.

Garmin does, however, have Apple beat when it comes to watch faces. The Apple Watch only supports first-party watch faces or ones made by Apple. It’s restricting and takes a lot of the fun out of owning a smartwatch. Garmin, on the other hand, has hundreds of first- and third-party watch faces available from the Connect IQ store. Many of them are paid, but you can find some decent free ones, too.

With digital payment support, you can pay for things in physical stores from both devices. The Apple Watch uses Apple Pay, while Garmin watches support Garmin Pay. These services make both sets of devices especially handy for long-distance runners and cyclists who want to leave their wallets at home.

Importantly, Apple’s watchOS software may offer more fluid animations and better touchscreen support, but that comes at a cost. Most Apple Watches can only last a day or two on a single charge. You might find yourself having to conserve battery power if you want to do power-intensive things like go for a run with GPS or track your sleep. Garmin watches benefit from the battery-saving properties of RTOS. Most Garmin devices, depending on their display type and size, can last anywhere from four days to two weeks on a charge. Some even have solar charging.

Apple Watch vs Garmin: Companion apps

Companion apps and services are a major part of each ecosystem. After all, it’s how you’ll dig into the data that your fitness watch collects. Both Garmin and Apple feature robust companion apps. If you own a Garmin device, you’ll use Garmin Connect to access your data. There’s a web version, as well as apps for Android and iOS. You can see all of your stats, from steps to training plans, on all three versions of Garmin Connect. Of course, some things like heart rate and GPS data can be easier to see on a full-fledged computer.

We’ve been critical of the Garmin Connect app. It’s extremely feature-packed, as there’s essentially little difference between the web and mobile versions, so the app can be difficult to navigate. Once you spend some time with it though, you’ll enjoy the benefits of the data-rich home screen, useful monthly calendar view, and the ability to create custom workouts, right inside the app. Garmin also has an entirely different app called Connect IQ for downloading watch faces, apps, and widgets. You can access Connect IQ on the web, Android, and iOS.

Apple’s setup is quite different from Garmin’s. There are four apps you need to know about, three of which we’ll talk about in this section. The first is the Watch app, which comes pre-installed on all iPhones, even if you don’t own an Apple Watch (cool move, Apple). The Watch app is where you’ll manage, download, and customize your watch faces, change app and notification settings, and more.

The Apple Fitness app is Apple’s, well, fitness-tracking app. It’s quite basic, in that it only shows your tracked fitness data from your Apple Watch or other Apple devices, including a summary of your daily activity, recent workouts, fitness and exercise trends, and any awards or achievements you’ve earned. Apple Fitness Plus requires a subscription and offers more training features, fitness classes, and resources but we’ll cover more on that below.

Apple Health is where all of your health data is stored. You can see your workouts and activity, but also your sleep, heart rate, nutrition, respiratory data, and much more. Apple Health can get quite convoluted too, unfortunately. We’ve found it to be a little too easy to get lost searching for the data you want. However, the app is saved by the Browse tab, which lets you narrow down your search using a search box, or by selecting from a variety of health categories.

When comparing Apple vs Garmin companion apps, it’s tough to choose which one comes out on top. Both Apple Health and Garmin Connect will take some time to get used to for new users. Garmin Connect is the better app for training metrics and custom workouts. Apple Health clearly displays all of your health data in an easy-to-navigate list, making it the better app for quickly viewing data.

Premium features

Apple jumped on the fitness subscription bandwagon with Apple Fitness Plus. It’s a premium service that can be accessed with or without an Apple Watch. The service costs users $9.99 a month or $79.99 a year. This fee gets you access to a variety of guided workout videos from some of the most popular trainers around the world. Video recommendations are tailored to your workout history, so if you’re a runner, cyclist, or devoted HIIT-er, there will be plenty of videos to suit your needs.

You can access Apple Fitness Plus through the App Store or via an Apple TV. One of the best parts of the platform is being able to exercise along with a workout video on your television and if wearing an Apple Watch, see your heart rate data on the big screen. Your Apple Watch will also automatically record the workout in the Apple Fitness app, so you don’t need to spend time setting up a specific workout in the app. We thoroughly enjoyed the service during our Apple Fitness review period, finding it both entertaining and refreshing. A free three-month trial comes with all new Apple Watch purchases.

Garmin does not offer workout videos, though some of its devices offer animated, on-device workouts. You can follow along with cardio, strength training, yoga, and Pilates workouts right on your smartwatch. This feature pales in comparison to Apple’s premium offering, but at least it’s free.

Garmin devices also come with a feature called Garmin Coach. This feature consists of free training plans that will help you run a 5K, 10K, half marathon, or a variety of cycling races with the help of professional athletes. Training plans are limited and advanced athletes might not get much out of them. However, they’re great for those who are starting their fitness journeys. Given that they are completely free, they’re a nice option to have on board.

Apple Watch vs Garmin: Which ecosystem is right for you?

If you came here hoping to find a clear winner, we’re sorry to say that it’s more nuanced than that. As we’ve covered, both platforms offer excellent fitness and health tracking features, high-end hardware, and data-packed applications.

The best Apple Watch is clearly the better smartwatch (if you own an iPhone, that is). Its high-resolution display and tight integration with iOS make for an all-around stellar experience. The Apple Watch is customizable, stylish, and can be (at times) affordable. It’s also incredibly versatile, making it a great fit for the office or the gym. The platform is made even better thanks to Apple Fitness Plus. For those willing to pay, the service is a convenient way to stay motivated and on track.

Garmin watches have their strengths too. Garmin’s wearables lineup covers virtually every price point from $150 to $1,000 and up. Whether you’re looking for a basic activity tracker or a do-everything fitness watch, you’re bound to find something in Garmin’s stable. We would also recommend choosing Garmin’s ecosystem for training purposes. Garmin’s fitness platform and workout analysis are more developed than Apple’s, though the latter continues to improve.

Garmin’s devices also offer more buttons for navigation than all Apple Watches. Many Garmin users cite this as a major strength of the platform’s devices. A touchscreen can be hard to use when sweaty or wearing gloves. The Apple Watch Ultra is the first Apple Watch to add an Action button to address the issue.

Finally, there’s one major area where Apple just can’t seem to make any progress, and that’s battery life. Sure the Apple Watch Ultra offers improvement, but its battery life is still woefully short compared to many Garmin devices. Buy a Garmin watch if you don’t want to have to worry about battery life. It’s as simple as that.

FAQs

We know the Apple Watch vs Garmin debate can get pretty heavy sometimes, but we’ll throw caution to the wind. Which side are you on? Have you tried both? Neither? Let us know your thoughts in the comments.