Sony Xperia Z gets pitted against HTC Butterfly, wins the benchmark battle

February 11, 2013
30 63 9

HTC-Butterfly-vs-Sony-Xperia-Z-2

HTC might have had the honor of releasing the world’s first ever Full HD smartphone, but the technology world doesn’t (necessarily) work based on the “first come, first served” principle. Even if the “first come” has been the only one at the table for several months.

There’s plenty of 1080p competition for the Butterfly (aka J Butterfly, aka Droid DNA), but it’s obvious the battle for supremacy will be carried against Sony’s Xperia Z. At least until HTC and Samsung’s own Full HD giants will have to have their hunger for celebrity quenched.

So now the question that needs to be answered is who’s the champ. The Butterfly or the Z? As you’d expect, there’s no simple answer we can offer yet, but a few complicated ones come via Taiwan. EPrice has scored a pre-release prototype of the Xperia Z, which it has quickly pitted against a commercial version of the Butterfly in a few key battles.

HTC-Butterfly-vs-Sony-Xperia-Z

Our Chinese is not very fluent, so we may be missing a few details, but, in a nutshell, the Z seems to narrowly come out on top, mostly due to an unexpected edge in the hardware department. Unexpected, because the two phones have identical quad-core 1.5 GHz Snapdragon S4 Pro chips, 2 gigs of RAM and Adreno 320 GPUs beneath their hoods and 5-inch Full HD panels.

Z’s upper hand is noticeable in all benchmarks performed by EPrice, including reputable tests like Quadrant, NenaMark, AnTuTu or Vellamo. Granted, the score gaps are not massive anywhere, but for Android power users they are very likely to make a difference.

HTC-Butterfly-vs-Sony-Xperia-Z-3

Fortunately for HTC, it’s not all about hardware and benchmarks in EPrice’s comparison. And out of the four remaining battles (design, display, sound and camera), the Butterfly comes out with two ties and two wins.

The (narrow) wins are scored in the display and sound departments, while the design and camera duels seem to end in draws. Obviously, all of these, in the absence of hard numbers, are far more subjective than the benchmark battle, so their results are more easily questionable.

Be that as it may, you probably can’t deny the extra sharpness of Butterfly’s panel. The Xperia Z and Butterfly have equally bright displays, but the color perception and viewing angles are considerably better on HTC’s machine.

HTC-Butterfly-vs-Sony-Xperia-Z-4

As for the cameras, you and me will most likely have different views (as always), but here’s my two cents. Z’s 13 MP snapper is at its best in night mode, while Butterfly’s 8 MP shooter produces clearer and more natural pics in “normal” lighting conditions.

That’s about everything we could read between the lines in EPrice’s head-to-head comparison of the two coolest Android smartphones around. Obviously, there are other things that you have to take into account before making your decision, like software differences, the battery life or Z’s dust and water proofing.

But we’ll probably talk more about those once we or someone else grabs a commercial version of the Z, available already in Japan and expected soon all around the world.

Comments

  • SonyFan

    Can’t belive that sound is better in HTC than Sony
    Design is just taste…

    • http://twitter.com/danmcsw danmcsw

      I’m finding that a bit hard to believe as well. I’ve always felt that Xperia models have much nicer sound when I compared them to their HTC competitor. It was, and still is one of my favourite things about Sony, even when Sony may have been a bit behind in other areas like cpu performance, you could always count on the sound being sweet.
      Also, the loudspeaker on HTC phones has regularly been a major weak point. They seem tinny and really raspy compared to Xperia models. So I am puzzled to see HTC win on sound.

    • Ivan Budiutama

      Might be a subjective case, as you know beats audio vs walkman all around. For people with a specific taste of (over the top, to my taste) bass might see beats as the winner. But for balance, I think Sony would be better, not to mention that Sony headset probably will be better than any beats (over expensive to my taste) headset. (never be a fans of beats audio btw, so my opinion is highly subjective on this mater).

  • simon t

    Sony, anyday,

  • rufaz

    the problem with Z’s sound isnt quite good is because of waterproofing feature. remove that, i can assure you that sony would sound better. :)

  • me

    I will never agree that htc has better sound. Ive tried many htc handsets and beats audio is just utter garbage. Completely unnatural, packed with so many low boost and enchancements – thats not what i call good sound quality. Beats go nowhere near sony’s natural reproduction quality.

  • http://www.facebook.com/RANZST Dmranzst TwoGm

    HTC products like a fragile glass..,,, take a look in this video in youtube /watch?v=fBRsWQGw1P4 like a china phone..

  • http://www.facebook.com/tarcisiorm TarcĂ­sio Medeiros

    What I see is a Sony Xperia Z against HTC One X on benchmark o_O

  • soham

    sony is so much better.