When Google announced the so called Samsung Galaxy S4 “Google Edition” at Google I/O, many people were quite surprised. HTC decided to bring its own variant of the One to the party, leading us to believe that the time when OEMs give us the choice between their skin and stock Android is coming soon.
So which phone should you buy on June 26th? Stick around as we analyze the two smartphones in question so that you can make the right decision.
Remember this is a comparison for the Nexus experience versions of these smartphones, so if you’re looking for the review of the original Galaxy S4 click here, and if you’re looking for the review of the original HTC One click here.
First off we need to explain a few things. Neither the Galaxy S4 or the HTC One will come with the features that are in TouchWiz and Sense. So that means no Air View, Smart Scroll, Drama Shot or any of the other features that come standard in TouchWiz.
There won’t be any floating touch input on the Galaxy S4 Google Edition
The HTC One won’t be able to take Zoes, or use Blink Feed, or any of the other features that are a part of Sense, except for Beats Audio. The audio technology will be found inside the HTC One with Nexus user experience, but there won’t be a toggle to turn it on and off.
That means that both the Galaxy S4 and the HTC One will be running pure, unaltered stock Android, so hardware is the only real difference between the two.
Both the HTC One and the Galaxy S4 have the same Snapdragon 600 processor, and while the S4 is clocked at a slightly higher speed, it won’t make much of a difference when it comes to real life usage.
Real life usage should be buttery smooth on both devices.
The GPUs are also the same, the Adreno 320 GPU provides great performance for both smartphones, meaning you’ll be able to play high-end games for years to come. 2GB of RAM is provided on both the Galaxy S4 and the HTC One, so again no differences here either.
The display is one of the most important parts of a smartphone since all of your interaction with the device comes through the display. Rest assured, both these smartphones come with glorious Full HD displays that are best in class.
The HTC One comes with a Full HD Super LCD3 display, which renders some of the most accurate colors on the market. Thanks to its slightly smaller 4.7-inch screen, it also has the highest pixel density of any smartphone, at 469 PPI.
The Galaxy S4 uses the ever familiar Super AMOLED technology, giving it the searing blacks and vibrant colors that it has become known for. The Galaxy S4’s larger 5-inch display means that although it has the same Full HD resolution as the HTC One, it has a slightly lower pixel density of 441 PPI.
Now this minute difference in pixel densities isn’t going to prove to be a real difference, so if you like accurate colors go with the HTC One, but if you prefer the vibrancy of an AMOLED go with the Galaxy S4.
From our extensive comparison of the HTC One’s much vaunted UltraPixel camera against the Samsung Galaxy S4’s 13 megapixel shooter, we found that the Galaxy S4 bested the HTC One on many fronts, however, without the software optimizations from Samsung and HTC, the camera capabilities and qualities of the two could change.
Galaxy S4 — studio shot, auto ISO. Click to enlarge.
HTC One — studio shot, auto ISO. Click to enlarge.
If you want to check out our full comparison of the two cameras, click here.
The HTC One with Nexus user experience might have lost some of its software features, but what it hasn’t lost is its incredible build quality which sets it apart from other Android manufacturers. The dual front facing speakers are sure to provide the best audio experience from a smartphone and it has all the standard features of a high end smartphone like NFC, Bluetooth 4.0 and 4G LTE capability.
The Galaxy S4 with Nexus user experience loses all of its “smart” feature, but depending on where you stand on that you might take this as good news. The Galaxy S4 can’t compete with the HTC One on the build quality front, but that does open up room for some fan favourites like a microSD card and a removable battery, it also has all the standard features of the HTC One.
Removable battery and a MicroSD slot remain on the Galaxy S4 with Nexus user experience
Both phones aren’t winning any awards for best battery life, but they should be able to get you through a whole day. However, the Galaxy S4 does have a removable battery if you need the insurance of a second battery.
Always high up on the deciding factors list, the price of the smartphones is comparable. Both the devices are nowhere near the Nexus 4 in terms of price, the HTC One comes in at $599 and the Galaxy S4 at $649. That saving of $50 might seem small, but that’s the price of the 32GB variant of the HTC One, and while the Galaxy S4 comes with 16GB inbuilt, the microSD card slot can boost storage up as well.
With the Samsung Galaxy S4 and the HTC One both providing a Nexus user experience, the choice becomes less about software and more about hardware. So if you prefer the build and dual speakers of the HTC One, then that is the phone you should pick, but if a removable battery and an expandable MicroSD card slot appeal to you, then the Galaxy S4 is the obvious choice.
The Nexus 4 is still a solid choice.
Of course you shouldn’t forget about the Nexus 4, still a solid choice for a much lower price. So if stock Android is your main objective and timely updates are what you’re after, but bleeding edge specifications aren’t a necessity, perhaps you can save some cash and grab the Nexus 4.
If you’re still tossing up between the HTC One and the Galaxy S4, head to your local carrier and put both of them in your hands and decide that way, because everything else will be exactly the same.
So what will it be, HTC One, Nexus 4 or Samsung Galaxy S4? Let us know in the poll and continue the debate in the comments below.
What phone are you buying on June 26?
HTC One with Nexus user experience
Samsung Galaxy S4 with Nexus user experience
What phone are you buying on June 26?
Like this post? Share it!
I would rather go for Nexus 4!
I went that route. Then got tired of crappy battery life
May be, but why should i waste $300-$350 extra for nothing in that case? I shall buy two spare batteries:)
Really? I get a pretty good battery life with a custom kernel.
Of course both of these devices support LTE on AT&T and T-Mobile while the Nexus 4 doesn’t (unless you count a hack to get LTE on TMo).
Neither. I will wait for the “Nexus 4S” with LTE and 32 GB.
why with the S at the end. you should just use apple products since you like their names
To be honest, stock Android is kinda boring. I have both a Nexus 7 and Galaxy S3 and far prefer the flexibility and features on TouchWiz.
Ha good joke
Speed has not been a problem on t-mobile, so nexus 4 for me. The HTC One and the Samsung S4 are not worth the extra $250 the would cost over the nexus, I’d rather use the savings on a nexus 7 tablet.
Until they start using on screen buttons…neither.
gonna keep my Nexus 4. Isnt like it cant take avg shoots and play games!
wating for the next nexus, them I will choose where to jump!
If I’d buy an S4, I’d buy the TouchWiz one just because all the execlusive features. Without them the S4 isn’t worth 650$
HTC ONE for price and design
Honestly I’d need to see what features each loses to be sure which would be best both are great phones in their own right, how much of their uniqueness will be lost under “GE” remains to be seen… I’ll probably skip it for now… Note 3 “Google Experience” maybe???
One loses its beautiful new Sense, while s4 doesn’t lose anything amazing. S4 it is, the only “Nexus” with removable battery and sd card slot
uff que bonitos todos *.*
HTC One: It really is worth the extra $250 over the Nexus 4, just for the Better Screen, Better Camera, Better Speakers, Actual usable space for Apps, and a Back that won’t break like Batman over Bane’s knee.
Much better CPU? I have over clocked my nexus 4 to 1.7 GHz and score pretty much the same as the HTC one. Even without over clocking the socs are very similar having same GPU and ram and only a .2 GHz difference
That’s great that Touch Wiz is removed from the S4. The HTC One without the Sense UI is not worth buying because the device won’t be that attractive combined with its premium build quality which is better than any other phone on the market right now, because the Sense UI is good for HTC’s smartphones. Galaxy S4 without it’s TouchWiz UI is worth buying because the device gets easier to use with Stock Android UI compared with Samsungs Touch Wiz UI.
For the same price you could get a n4 and n7. I would rather an actual nexus over these ‘Google editions’ mainly just due to the fact that it will likely get a better developer community. The specs of the n4 aren’t far off the HTC one anyway( especially with a slight over clock)
with stock android how smooth Gs4 will be hmm
Probably the same level of smoothnessas the htc one with sense, or maybe a little but better since after all, it is stock android
the s4 is already very laggy and i don’t think stock android will make it any better.maybe 0.1 percent less laggy but it will still be laggy
i noticeably did not vote, as “none of the above”, which should always be listed on “ANY” ballot was not included [that would have been my selection!] As for my take on this ‘coming out party’ – it is to me a bit of a ‘kindergarten’ event. Samsung is planning a ‘naa, naa, i told you so’ approach, hoping that the effect will be to disappoint the majority who miss the addon Samsung ‘extras’ and vow to buy ‘the ‘real thing’ next time; hoping the bloatWare being missing does not support the opposite reaction. And as for the HTC one, it seems to be a simple basic ‘me too, me too’, reaction.
Argh…it’d be no contest (for me) if the One had a removable battery & SD slot. That said…I’ll stick with my good ol’ One S a while longer.
Wow, surprise the HTC One has got 60% of the votes! I would personally go for the Galaxy S4 NE because of really two reasons that have been mentioned soo many times; but if the choice included the TouchWiz version, I would go for the TouchWiz.
What is the touchWiz? Show me a picture please.
Its basically a piece of software Samsung adds on top of Android. You see how a Samsung Galaxy phone looks different from a HTC Android phone when using features like camera & music player? That is because of TouchWiz. HTC uses something called Sense on its phones – that is what makes stuff like music player and camera different from Samsung Galaxy phones.
nexus 4 is not an alternative for me as it has no sd slot and less than 13gb available memory. i dont want to carry an usb stick around with me just because google decided people get confused by sd cards. believe me, google, nexus users can handle that confusing technology.
whats the point to these phones when both can be unlocked and rooted? ( as far as i know)
I dont quiet understand the advantage to them?
I would consider buying S4 Nexus if it is priced around $350-$450. Nothing more than that! It will be over priced(Including Htc one).
How come no one ever mentions the enormous bezel around One’s display? And I hope whoever thought of making only two buttons burns in hell. Yeah, other than that AND the awful camera HTC One is a great phone :P
A year ago everyone was crying about how it would be so great if XYZ phone was stock, people were sickened that they weren’t on Jelly Bean, it was a million articles bashing skins…NOW that you get what you so loudly asked for it’s a dumb idea, you love your skins, not being on most recent Android build is no big deal…
REALLY PEOPLE! REALLY?!?!?!