Google Search vs Siri: Apple’s assistant can’t match the power of Google’s Search

June 30, 2012
0 43 14 15

    One of the main Android 4.1 Jelly Bean highlights is without a doubt the new Google Search, an app that has been completely redesigned to offer Android device users quicker results and an improved overall experience. The new Google Search app now has an advanced voice component and offers a Google Now feature that can be used as a personal assistant when having to deal with various day-to-day activities. Therefore, Jelly Bean has its own voice-assistant, and while it’s not called Majel, as we would have expected it to be named, it definitely does its job.

    Piper Jaffray analyst Gene Munster decided to put the two to the test in a Google Search vs Siri battle, by asking both an iPhone and an Android device 1,600 questions: 800 in a quiet environment and 800 in “the busy streets of Minneapolis”. Unsurprisingly, Google won. I say unsurprisingly because let’s not forget that Google’s day job is Search. The company owns a huge chunk of worldwide online searches, because that’s how it makes money. Google’s main revenue stream comes from online ads, and that’s why updating the Search component in Android is so important.

    On the other hand, Siri is not Apple’s search engine but a voice assistant that uses various online resources to come up with answers to the user’s queries. According to Munster, Siri gets 60% of answers from Google, 20% from Yelp, 14% from WolframAlpha, 4% from Yahoo and 2% from Wikipedia, and it’s lagging more than two years behind Google “in its learning curve”.

    An updated Siri version is supposed to come out this fall when iOS 6 gets official, while the new Google Search engine will be available on all Android devices that will support Jelly Bean – we don’t have official update details for most of them.

    With that in mind, here are the results of this Google Search vs Siri battle:

    • Google understands 100% of the questions (not surprisingly, since they are keyed in)
    • Google replies accurately 86% of the time
    • Siri comprehends 83% of queries in noisy conditions, 89% in a quiet room
    • Siri answers accurately 62% of the time on the street and 68% in a quiet room.

    And here are some of the errors made by Siri during testing:

    • What team does Peyton Manning play for? Responded with the answer to the previous query. This was the most common error.
    • Where is Elvis buried? Responded I can’t answer that for you. It thought the persons name was Elvis Buried.
    • Where am I? Pin dropped in the wrong place.
    • When did the movie Cinderella come out? Responded with a movie theater search on Yelp.
    • How do I get from Boston to New York? Responded I can only give directions from your current location. I cant give you directions to a place you are not in.
    • What spices are in Lasagna? Responded with a Yelp search with lasagna on the menu.
    • When is the next Haley’s comment? Responded “You have no meetings matching Haley’s”
    • I want to go to Lake Superior? Responded with directions to the company Lake Superior X-Ray.

    Anyone looking forward to using the new Google Search on Jelly Bean devices?

    0 43 14

    Comments

    • http://twitter.com/Nashstruck Nashstruck

      A video review would be nice.

      • NeedName

        There are several on youtube already

    • Thegdude

      I just got a leaked version of jellybean for my galaxy nexus and Google Now(new Google search) is without a doubt the best voice-activated search I’ve ever used.

    • Robert Mitchell

      If Siri can not keep up technically, I am sure Apple will find some way to sue.

      • Harry

        I highly doubt that Apple cannot keep up with anyone since they could almost buy everyone in tech apart from Google outright including Sammy… they’re just too ignorant and arrogant

        • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_GQEBUC32IAVQA4L3G4T42SIU4E Muhammad Faiz

          Nah I don’t think they can buy Samsung. Samsung is as huge as Apple. Furthermore, iphone parts are made by Samsung. They could work together, like they are doing now, but they cannot buy big, successful companies like Samsung. It’s possible if Samsung is falling apart.

    • http://www.webstatsart.com/ Webstats Art

      Siri is in beta but it is improving all the time. Apple fans are not going away sometime soon. The whole experience of Siri is simply way cooler than anything google can come up with. Don’t ask me why.. it is just a fact.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_GQEBUC32IAVQA4L3G4T42SIU4E Muhammad Faiz

        It is a “fact” but you can’t answer it… LOL. I rather have a functional voice assistant than one that can apparently tell “jokes”.

      • NeedName

        apple fans are accustomed to living in a RDF world where incorrect information is their norm anyway. . . so, nothing will change for them with siri.

      • http://www.facebook.com/justin.ferguson.1612 Justin Ferguson

        I think the fact you are trying to allude to is the fact that apple fanatics, “fans,” will always flock to an inferior product or service because of its affiliation to a fruit.

        • http://www.webstatsart.com/ Webstats Art

          Apple fans aren’t looking for cheap discounts and imitations.

          • NeedName

            So that’s why they continue to support a company that stole the GUI form Xerox — apple only paid for a demo, not to use the IP — and stole the iPod design form the original inventor of the portable digital music player, and put out a knock-off of Palm’s PDA+Blackbery (we won’t talk about iTune)?

            I see. . . . wait, no I don’t. What is the ‘patent trolling fruit company’s’ truly original invention? You know, that ONE invention they created that wasn’t totally based on someone else’s prior work.

            I’ll be waiting. . . as of yet NO apple fan has been able to produce just ONE truly *original* invention from the ‘patent trolling fruit company.’

      • Ayman Kouzayha

        so SIRI will be in beta for 2 years to catch up with Google Search,,
        supposing that time is going to stop for Google, lol

    • Farrah Collins

      Guys should check out this new social network. http://www.Formvote.com , I asked this same question there so it kind of reminded me of it lol. But I’d go with Siri!

    • zarometro

      So what would happen if you’d tell Google Search to send a text to one of your contacts???
      I would be surprised if Google had the app that would work the worst when doing a search but, in my opinion, both apps have different purposes.

    Popular

    Latest