Google Nexus 4 vs Apple iPhone 5

November 21, 2012

     

     

    The battle for your cash in the smartphone market has never been fiercer. Google just released its latest Nexus device, the LG-manufactured Nexus 4, and Apple’s iPhone 5 is still fairly fresh on the scene. They go up against established Android heavyweights like the Samsung Galaxy S3 and the HTC One X. In the background we have Microsoft’s newly launched Windows Phone 8 and what’s that coming over the hill? It’s BlackBerry 10.

    We all know the real fight right now is down to Android and iOS. There are two big bouts in the tablet market, iPad mini vs Nexus 7, and iPad vs Nexus 10, but the main event sees Google’s flagship smartphone up against Apple’s. It’s the Nexus 4 vs the iPhone 5, and there can be only one winner.

    Display

    The display is the first thing you notice about any phone and the trend in high-end smartphones has been drifting towards “bigger is better” for a while now. The Nexus 4 has a 4.7-inch True HD IPS Plus display with a resolution of 1280 x 768 pixels, which is 318ppi (pixels per inch). The iPhone 5 has a 4-inch backlit LED IPS display with a resolution of 1136 x 640 pixels, which is 326ppi.

    The Nexus 4 offers full HD resolution, but the iPhone 5 offers an imperceptibly greater pixel density. The Nexus 4 is supposed to have more natural color reproduction, but it can look a little washed out next to some displays. Visibility in sunlight and viewing angles are good, but the iPhone 5 display is brighter and features richer colors. Both have Gorilla Glass 2 protection.

    The Nexus 4, even with onscreen virtual buttons, offers a lot more screen real estate, but the iPhone 5’s display is slightly better quality.

    Design and feel

    The iPhone 5 is smaller and lighter than the Nexus 4. The Nexus 4 weighs in at 139g versus the iPhone 5 at 112g. In terms of measurements the Nexus 4 is 133.9mm x 68.7mm x 9.1mm and the iPhone 5 is 123.8mm x 58.6mm x 7.6mm. Apple made a big deal about the fact that the iPhone 5 is exactly the same width as the iPhone 4S so you can comfortably hold it and use the touchscreen one-handed. The iPhone 5 is just taller than its predecessor. The comfort factor depends on the size of your hands really.

    The Nexus 4 feels more solid and the extra weight is something that some people find reassuring. That solid feel was often cited as a reason that the old iPhone felt high quality and reassuringly expensive. The Nexus 4 features glass on the back and when the light catches it you’ll see a holographic pattern. The body of the phone is plastic and the edges are curved like previous Nexus devices. There are no physical buttons on the front and you’ll find the power button on the right edge and the volume controls on the left edge, just like the Galaxy S3. It’s comfortable to hold, but it is fatter and heavier than the S3 which makes it way bigger than the iPhone 5.

    Apple switched to aluminum for the iPhone 5 body to reduce the weight and the back glass panel from the iPhone 4S is gone. It is a svelte device and it does feel extremely light. One of the drawbacks of the new anodized aluminum body is that it scuffs and chips easily which leads to the silver aluminum showing through.

    If you have small hands or you really want a lightweight device then the iPhone 5 wins out, but the Nexus 4 has a stylish design and it feels more solid.

    iphone-5-torture-test-1

    User interface and platform

    Here we have the latest and greatest version of Android, 4.2 Jelly Bean, up against Apple’s iOS 6. Android wins hands down. It looks better, there are more customization options, it’s very intuitive to use, it’s fast and smooth….the list goes on. Go ahead and take a look at the name of the site. That’s right, we like Android round here.

    Without going into a big iOS vs Android battle (that’s a whole other article) we can give the nod to iOS for having more high quality premium apps and games (Android is catching up, but there is no getting away from the fact that iOS boasts more high-end polished apps and games right now). On the other hand, Android’s Google apps are second to none, so whether you want to watch a YouTube video, continue your desktop browsing on Chrome on your phone, or get directions to a destination, an Android phone is the better choice.

    LG Nexus 4

    Processor and RAM

    Is the Nexus 4 faster than the iPhone 5? That’s all you really want to know in this section so we’ll dig a little deeper. The Nexus 4 has a 1.5GHz quad-core Qualcomm Snapdragon S4 Pro processor and 2GB of RAM. The iPhone 5 has a 1GHz dual-core A6 processor and 1GB of RAM. Despite the big number gap Apple’s internal architecture design is very strong and it always squeezes impressive performance from lower spec hardware.

    Benchmark tests on various sites show clearly that the Nexus 4 is the fastest Android smartphone on the market right now. What’s less clear is whether it nails the iPhone 5 on real-world performance. The tests show that the Nexus 4 outperforms the iPhone 5 on CPU and GPU performance some of the time, but they also show the iPhone 5 winning some of the time. The Nexus 4 seems to edge the win overall, but it’s not as clear cut as expected.

    Storage

    It looks like both companies are aiming to make a little cash on storage. Neither phone has a microSD card slot. You are limited to the internal storage that ships. The Nexus 4 is either 8GB or 16GB and the iPhone 5 is 16GB, 32GB or 64GB. You can buy a 16GB microSD card for a little over $10, but Google is charging $50 for 8GB and Apple is charging $100 for 16GB and then another $100 for the extra 32GB.

    You can always use cloud services to boost that amount, but for people who like to store their whole music collection or TV shows and movies on their smartphones the Nexus 4 looks limited and the iPhone 5 looks expensive.

    Cameras

    On paper we have an 8-megapixel rear-facing camera on both devices and the list of options and features is virtually identical. Both support 1080p video recording as well. The front-facing camera on the Nexus 4 is rated slightly higher at 1.3-megapixels compared to 1.2-megapixels, but as camera experts will tell you there’s a lot more to camera performance than the megapixel count.

    The good news is that both cameras are fast, they perform well in low-light conditions, and they’ll satisfy most smartphone owners. The iPhone 5 has the Panorama feature, but the Nexus 4 has Photo Sphere.

    Battery

    This one is straightforward for a change, or so you would think. The Nexus 4 has a much bigger battery at 2100mAh compared to the 1440mAh battery in the iPhone 5. It does also have a bigger display, but with no LTE to drain it you’d still expect better battery life from the Nexus 4. On paper it should offer 15 hours of talk time to the iPhone 5’s 8 hours and 390 hours of standby to the iPhone 5’s 225 hours.

    In practice things are always different and battery life will depend on exactly how you use your phone. We’ve already seen claims that the iPhone 5 outlasts the Nexus 4 for web browsing. Realistically both phones should last you at least a day between charges on normal use and the Nexus 4 should generally outlast the iPhone 5.

    Connectivity

    This section is all about what’s missing. The Nexus 4 does not support LTE and the iPhone 5 does not support NFC.

    LTE looks to be the bigger omission. In simple terms the LTE networks that are rolling out are potentially the fastest around. In practice the HSPA+ that the Nexus 4 does support offers good speeds that are comparable in many places. As LTE expands this could become more of an issue. Google has claimed the lack of LTE is about battery life and cost. The Verge makes a pretty convincing argument that it has more to do with carriers and Google’s desire to maintain control and not compromise the device.

    We think NFC has a lot of potential, but adoption is slow right now and the fact that the iPhone 5 doesn’t support it will not speed things along. If NFC does take off in the next year then you can bet Apple will add it into the next iPhone release.

    Everything else in terms of connectivity is pretty neck and neck except for Apple’s new proprietary Lightning connector. That renders all those old iOS accessories with the old connector dock useless unless customers buy an adapter for $30 or $40. This is typical Apple, finding another way to rake in those profits.

    Value for money

    On contract you’ll get an iPhone 5 or a Nexus 4 for $199. Google is really all about selling unlocked smartphones and the company is offering the 8GB Nexus 4 for a shockingly low $299. If you want the 16GB version then you’ll need to spend $349. If you wanted to buy an unlocked 16GB iPhone 5 you’d need to shell out $649. For the 32GB model you’ll pay $749 and the 64GB model is a whopping $849.

    The Nexus 4 is obviously better value for money.

    iphone-5-torture-test-3

    ….and the winner is

    The Nexus 4 has to take the title. It offers freedom to choose the exact setup you want in terms of customizing the phone and buying an unlocked device with a plan of your choice. Most people will also want to take advantage of that bigger screen and let’s not forget that it is super-fast.

    If you want to get a contract deal and the LTE support is important to you then the iPhone 5 is probably going to look more attractive. When we think about the way people buy phones and the importance of carrier relations it’s clear that Google has some work to do. How many people buy unlocked smartphones on the Internet? Apple will obviously sell more iPhone 5 units, but early sales of the Nexus 4 look good if the selling out is anything to go by. Of course, sales aren’t really a good measure of what the best phone is. You always have to weigh up budget and features and choose the best phone for you.

    To be honest if I was offered an iPhone 5 or a Nexus 4 right now I’d take the iPhone 5, but then I’d sell it, buy a Nexus 4 and keep the change. How about you?

    0 46 118

    Comments

    • PaviGuru

      Loving the last line. I’d probably do the same!

    • Nessim

      “To be honest if I was offered an iPhone 5 or a Nexus 4 right now I’d take the iPhone 5, but then I’d sell it, buy a Nexus 4 and keep the change. How about you?”
      Very smart!

    • http://profiles.google.com/djb.bell Darren Bell

      That last line… Yeah, just great. I would do that to.

    • NicholasMicallef

      The last line is exactly what I always think about any Apple device xD

    • MasterMuffin

      I can’t understand why people even ask which one’s better, nexus costs half the price of the iPhone end of discussion

      • http://Nepallica.com Pretush

        and almost same (or better) hardware specification.

      • Vboom

        By your logic you think a Ford is better than a Ferrari because its cheaper.
        Economy better than first class?
        Holiday Inn better than the Hilton?
        The Nexus is great but the price isn’t the reason!

        Pretush is right, if cost wasn’t a factor these phones are almost identical.
        Price just gets you over the line.

        • http://twitter.com/acsr333 acsr

          problem is iPhone is not a Ferrari, it’s just an overhyped phone

        • MasterMuffin

          By my logic, nexus is as good/better and costs half the price, smartass :)

          • Vboom

            Both great phones, nexus tops it with price included but if they were the same price I would go the iPhone. At the end of the day they aren’t the same price and as an apple fan I do agree the Nexus is better bang for your buck.
            Didn’t mean to start any arguments fellas.

            • MasterMuffin

              Apple fan :OOOOOOOO

              :D

        • krudd

          Close but no, its the ford that costs more than the ferrari here. iphone is not anything near that class. It’s like going to war with a blank firing adapter.

    • Just-Martin

      “To be honest if I was offered an iPhone 5 or a Nexus 4 right now I’d
      take the iPhone 5, but then I’d sell it, buy a Nexus 4 and keep the
      change. How about you?” – Brilliant.

      • Reginald Spence II

        Too true.

    • http://www.facebook.com/matt.black.52206654 Matt White

      hands down nexus kills the iphone im running a gs3 and it really kills the iphone it has lte expandable memory nfc beautiful screen and i love it so gs3 is my first pic!

    • Yvanho

      i’ll do the same to…lol

    • http://twitter.com/LiiIiikEaBau5 LiiIiikEaBau5

      Ordered my Nexus 4 yesterday! Wooo! Finally Norwegian can preorder their beloved smartphone! :D

    • Juanjosan

      The iPhone is a much better phone, excelent for instagram and Siri… NOT!!! Nexus devices are more customizable, iPhone 5 is just a bigger, thinner and faster iphone 1, same GUI, same OS, nothing new.

    • Dude1

      I would sell the nexus 4 to discount the iPhone 5. I can’t believe you made the case for no LTE is a good thing. And as for all your comments “blowing away” iPhone 5… how about some facts?

      http://www.anandtech.com/show/6324/the-iphone-5-performance-preview

      • Jacob Rojas

        http://browser.primatelabs.com/android-benchmarks

        nexus 4 and 10 (note the 1955 score is low, i posted 2189 just now)

        http://browser.primatelabs.com/ios-benchmarks

        iphone 5 and ipad 4 arent just left behind, they are crushed…

        • That guy

          I hate how android users always seem to want to throw down ios users. I get that all the time at work (cell phone salesman). I had both android phones and iphones. I went from the iphone 4 to galaxy s. I had the samsung moment, evo 4g, LG thrill, samsung focus (windows phone 7), and played with plenty of other android phones at work.

          I personally got tired of apps force closing on me, not being fully optimized with my device, my micro usb damaging after 3 months of use, apps eating up my ram requiring me to restart my phone, over complicated user interface that made simple tasks like simply making a phone call or texting too complicated for a phone, late updates or discontinued support etc etc.

          I made a simple and educated decision to go with a company that make their products with dedication and care, simple to use, with apps fully optimized with the hardware, good battery life, stable operating system, GREAT games that leave the competition in the dust, etc.

          Now, android has become much better in the recent months but the point is; if you made an educated decision to buy yourself a phone according to your liking you, dont need to tell the other person yours is better.

          Is the iphone 5 better than Nexus 4? It depends on your taste. Look, feel, functionality, now make your choice and be happy with it.

        • Nick

          The point is that the geekbench scores are only valid comparing similar hardware families. The fact that the android phones post higher geekbench but lower real life performance show that specs alone don’t make a phone.

          On the benchmarks, the real life tests show a different story. Anandtech has better real world performances on the current iPhone/iPad versus the android ilk.

    • sayem alvee

      bought an iphone 4S used from someone desperate for money, had it unlocked and put it out for sale; no box, no headphone and and I am getting offers of 2.5x for what i paid for. Gotta love those iSheep. Seriously wasn’t thinking of getting a Nexus 4 as I am in a contract [Rogers can very hard to deal with to get out of a contract] and a long way to go, but that used 4S might just pay for the 16GB Nexus and leave change for a Cover and even a couple of beers to go along making fun of iProducts

    • http://twitter.com/matter37 Matthew

      The carriers are assholes so I always buy unlocked.

    • wkwong11

      I have the Nexus 4 on T-Mobile. In Milpitas, CA, I have speeds up to 16Mbps down and 3Mbps up on HSPA+. Even at 5-6Mbps, it is already more than enough for everyday tasks. LTE is faster, but not necessary. Perhaps in two to three years when LTE networks are more widely available and phones have more processing power to really take advantage of the speeds will LTE be a necessity.

    • http://www.facebook.com/touayang11 Toua Yang

      Actually, I was thinking of selling my Nexus 4 and buying 2 Nexus 4s later when the supply meets the demand. That’s how hot this phone is right now. I still have my GNex which is still in perfect condition. Although, I think the 4.2 update made it just a tad slower. I notice lag when going through the widget screens.

      Nexus 4 is the best Andoird phone on the market. I would take the pure Google experience over any other manufacture branded phone.

    • mark

      Great review…totally unbiased. Seriously though, Android fanboys are the most delusional of all.

    • http://twitter.com/rippinkitten18 Law

      silly fandroids. I guess a Ford Focus is better then a Lexus gs 350. The difference between you fandroids, and actual consomers, is that consumers are not biased actually, unlike you guys, its all “APPLE SUCKS, APPLE IS TOO EXPENSIVE, APPLE IS OVERRATED, NO FEATURE BLAH BLAH BLAH. SCREEN IS TOO SMALL, ITS JUST A HALF INCH BIGGER” Thats it. A real consumer will consider all the positives and negatives of whatever phone they are reviewing. You punks are just flat out all hate on Apple. This article is a laughing joke. If you compare phone to phone, the ip5 will smoke nexus 4 off this planet. It’s not even close in competition. the iphone5 is the best built phone on the planet, and integrates so well with it’s o.s

      http://www.androidpolice.com/2012/11/19/android-4-2-gate-here-are-some-of-the-major-issues-plaguing-googles-newest-release/

      Sorry but as a consumer, I really need say what I had to say. You fandroids are really out of this planet.

      As a consumer, I first heard all this great shit about the S3. I”m using s3 as an example as it’s hailed as one of the greatest phones on the planet.

      ok, so the longer I hear about this phone, the more bad things I learn about this phone. The ip5 is the exactly oppososite of the S3. You first hear a lot of bad things about it, then you slowly start to see and hear more good things about it. It’s just really a comparison. Somebody’s gotta put you android nerds in thier place.

      • krudd

        The ford focus costs way more than the lexus, didn’t you know that? Or maybe you like paying more for less. Either way, iphone rolled over dead back in September when people found out that the lexus costs less.

    • David Bruce

      Great article, and yes, I’d take the Nexus 4 as well. I currently have a used Samsung Galaxy S Vibrant that works well, but the GPS issues annoy me regularly. This year I’ll be replacing it with the Nexus 4, staying with the unlimited 4g plan on T-Mobile at $30 per month. We also have the Nexus 7 and love it.
      There are tons of Apple lovers out there, and that’s fine, but I’ve lost love for the company for several reasons, their poor audio reproduction from all things iPod, their death-grip on their device settings, and now their off-base litigation attacks on competitors..

    • http://www.freshbrands.co.uk/ London Media Agency

      On Android Authority what chance did the iPhone really have?

    • commonsense805

      I find it absolutely hilarious that people get so upset over a PHONE. How petty your lives have become. Newsflash, NONE of us on here are considered normal consumers. Normal consumers do not hang out on wannabe tech boards and regurgitate other wannabe tech board information. Stop hating on one or the other platform and just be happy with what you purchased. I’ve owned both iPhones and Android devices, and they both are good and bad in certain areas. One is definitely not better than the other by any shot. They are just different. Nothing less, nothing more. Stop humping Google and stop humping Apple. Both companies want your money and could care less about anything else so let’s put the fairy-tale to bed. Good luck with your devices!

    • Markton’s Cool Animation

      Both are good but in terms of operating system I will choose nexus 4 for I really love the android os but in terms of phone specs I will choose iPhone 5 but its always what we have choose its not about the price or which of the two are good but how do we value the phone we have. Always to remember that choose a phone that fits with your lifestyle and affordable for you.

    Popular

    Latest