Samsung Galaxy S4 loses to iPhone 5 in ‘breakability’ test, and here’s why you should have seen it coming

April 30, 2013

    Samsung Galaxy S4 cracked
    Have you seen the Samsung Galaxy S4 vs Apple iPhone 5 drop test video that we posted recently? If so, then chances are that you already know how well the latest flagship smartphone from Samsung fares against the latest iPhone from Apple when it comes to kissing the pavement (spoiler: it doesn’t fare very well at all). But in case our video with panning slow motion replay still wasn’t enough to convince you, then we’ve got something new to show you.

    SquareTrade, a company that sells insurance for mobile phones, recently conducted its own Galaxy S4 vs iPhone 5 drop test — it was part of an even bigger test to find out the so-called “breakability score” of these phones — and yielded some very interesting results.

    First, not only did SquareTrade pretty much settle the debate on which device can handle drops better, but it also delivered drop test results that corroborated the results from our own. So what exactly came out of SquareTrade’s tests, anyway? In terms of breakability, which smartphone scored the highest?

    Numbers don’t lie

    Here’s the answer. When pitted against its predecessor, the Samsung Galaxy S3, as well as the Apple iPhone 5, the Samsung Galaxy S4 performed poorly in terms of durability and garnered and overall score of 7 out of 10 on the SquareTrade breakability scale. It’s nearly 50% more breakable than the iPhone 5, and it actually scored worse than the S3 which came before it.

    This short infographic from SquareTrade, which is titled, “How breakable is the new Samsung Galaxy S4?” says it all.

    SquareTrade GS4 infographic
    As the infographic says, “Samsung takes a step backward with the Galaxy S4″ since the older Galaxy S3 turned out better after going through the SquareTrade breakability test. While it did deliver better results in certain parts of the test — such as water resistance — it still failed in the overall test. And this finding is not something that’s limited to just SquareTrade’s test. We’ve seen it happen time and time again, in Samsung Galaxy S4 drop test videos available all over the Internet.

    First, take a look at the SquareTrade breakability test video from which all of the above-mentioned information is based.

    Then there’s this video from YouTube user GizmoSlip, which tests the Galaxy S4 against the Galaxy S3 and iPhone 5.

    And of course, don’t forget to check out our own Galaxy S4 vs iPhone 5 drop test here.

    So what’s the problem? Well, the problem is really quite clear. The Galaxy S4 is just a little too breakable for something that ought to be the best of what’s out there right now. And not only does it have a higher breakability level than one of its main competitors — not to mention its very own predecessor — it also seems to scratch easier and also scores worse in terms of grippability.

    But in all fairness to Samsung — as well as Corning, which is the company responsible for the Galaxy S4′s Gorilla Glass 3 screen — they can’t really take all of the blame here. It’s just nature at work. And every time a smartphone screen bends or breaks, it’s really mostly due to the the laws of physics.

    Gravity, how does it work?

    We have a theory that perhaps the reason why the Samsung Galaxy S4 is categorically worse than the iPhone 5 when it comes to drop tests is simply because it is not only bigger but also heavier. It’s both half an inch taller and half an inch wider as well as 20 grams heavier than the iPhone 5. And it’s also a wee bit thicker, which explains why a .50 caliber round from a sniper rifle can easily breeze through its center and make the screen peel right off in (mostly) one piece, as seen in one of the more extreme Galaxy S4 teardowns we found online.

    The bottom line is, the fact that the Samsung Galaxy S4 is somehow able to score high on a breakability test shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone at all. And if we had to pick the three biggest lessons we’ve learned about this whole thing so far, we’d say these are:

    1. Your “life companion” isn’t at all immune to the laws of nature; so
    2. You shouldn’t bring a Samsung Galaxy S4 to a gun fight; and
    3. If we can all just keep our smartphones in our pockets, that’d be great.

    You may now read the detailed findings from SquareTrade’s breakability test in the press release embedded below.

    Show Press Release

    SquareTrade’s Breakability Score Debuts as New Richter Scale for Device Danger – New Samsung S4 Rated a Dangerous 7

    New Scorecard Fills Gap Left By Traditional Product Reviews and Calculates Danger in Everyday Situations

    SAN FRANCISCO, April 29, 2013 /PRNewswire/ – SquareTrade®, the top-rated protection plan trusted by millions of happy customers, today announced its Breakability Score™ for the new Samsung Galaxy S®4. The SquareTrade Breakability Score ranks today’s top devices based on how prone they are to break due to accidents. Evaluating key elements such as front and back panel design, edge construction and materials, size, weight, friction quotient, water resistance and grip-ability, SquareTrade’s Breakability Score fills in the missing gap left by traditional device reviews: it tests devices in everyday danger situations brought on by our lifestyles and habits.

    “Our Breakability Score creates a new Richter Scale for accidental damage to help consumers assess when, where and how their phones are in danger,” said Ty Shay , CMO at SquareTrade. “It’s been two years since we created the first Drop Test video for the industry and we thought it was time to expand the concept.”

    The SquareTrade Breakability Score is based on a number of factors, from physical characteristics to the results of our SquareTrade Drop Test. The higher a device scores on a scale from 1-10, the higher the risk of it breaking due to an accident.

    Comparing the Samsung Galaxy S4 to the S3 and Apple’s iPhone®5, the iPhone 5 was the clear winner. SquareTrade’s Breakability Score revealed the following:

    While the S4 proved slightly more water resistant than its predecessor the S3, Samsung’s new Galaxy phone actually performed worse in most other categories. Major strikes against the S4 include high breakability during SquareTrade Drop Tests, a slippery back panel, and a wider screen that reduces grip-ability, especially compared to the ultra-slim iPhone 5. Breakability Score: 7
    While the Samsung S3 screen is more durable, it is less water resistant than the S4 and its plastic back and wide width decreases its grip-ability. Breakability score: 6.5
    The iPhone 5 scored the highest of the three phones tested. While it lost points for its larger size due to more breakable surface area, its excellent grip-ability and low friction coefficient make it far more durable overall. Breakability Score: 5

    “Our research and experience shows that even the smallest device characteristics can dramatically affect its breakability: the weight balance of a device can affect the way it spins in free-fall, making it more likely to land on its screen; devices with rubber backs are less likely to slide, and device dimensions can effect how snugly smartphones fit in pant and jeans pockets,” continued Shay. “The likelihood of damage due to these common scenarios has never been higher.”

    Comments

    • RarestName

      Moral of the story: don’t drop your freakin’ phone.

      • Larkhillv

        Sometimes, things just happen. I am pretty careful with my phone, and I have dropped it a couple of times during the year and a half I’ve had it. I always keep a case on mine, though, so my phone is pretty much undamaged. But even if you’re super careful all the time, accidents happen.

      • http://twitter.com/piyushr21 Piyush

        atleast people will stop the plastic durability bashing like a fanboy and samsung will up the game in design process .

      • the2000guy

        I Have a better one, dont be cheap and by a protective case. How could someone pay $200+ dollars for a smartphone and you dont consider buying a protective case? I know that there is people who love to show their smartphone, and other prefer dont like the idea of a case but it is a need. Unless you have enough money to replace it every month LOL.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=714859472 Rajvir Singh

      Ofcourse it would be more breakable cause it has a bigger screen in a smaller frame than the S3 so the area of impact is bigger, ie, the bigger the glass the easier to shatter…
      I would go for a Tempered Glass screen protector if I wanted to keep any of these phones without a case…

    • Abdul

      Just buy a case, a metal one maybe to get the “premium” feel which most people want as well as durability.

    • societyofosiris

      I have yet to see a drop test simulate real-life drop situations. People think I am crazy for not keeping a case on my Galaxy Note II but then again I am not butterfingers and I don’t drop my phone from head-height while on a call. Usual drop scenarios are from; shirt pockets while leaning over, from pants while pulling the phone out, from navel-high while looking at video and off a table. I have dropped my phone on all sorts of material from asphalt to hard-wood floors and my favorite: a puddle. My device has yet to take any serious damage. I can’t speak for the S4 but my fiancé and time will tell. To my knowledge she has already dropped it once and no damage to speak of yet.

    • masterdebater

      I am still cringing from all the torture.

    • JanetheAddiction

      Calling a “phone” a “life companion” displays a clear lack of reality – a blow up doll is closer.

      • Mike Reid

        B.U.D. just seems like funny plastic* to me.

        But to each, their own. ;)

        (* or polycarbonate ?)

    • djsammy

      ah, you forget point 4:

      4. Don’t bring your “life companion” to bathroom or anywhere near water, it’s NOT even IPX4 certified (splash water -proof).

    • http://www.facebook.com/jermaine.bennett Jermaine Rafael Bennett

      I dropped my iphone 4s and the screen cracked almost every time .I dropped my galaxy note 2 hundreds of times and I barely have a scratch.

      • peter steffek

        you probably should be more careful.

    • http://www.facebook.com/patrick.smithopolis Patrick Smithopolis

      It depends on the point of impact. I dropped my S3 from my ear. It fell on it’s back and the screen stayed intact. I dropped my S3 a couple of months later from my pant pocket. It fell on one of its corner and the screen cracked and the digitizer went completely black.

    • b

      I have the note 2 and dropped it two days after I got it. It landed on the corner and stayed on the screen. So nervous when I was picking it up. My case arrived two days later. So lucky

    • Jess

      I dropped my iPhone 5 the minute i unpacked it and the screen shattered :/

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Rob-Hostetter/100001511027075 Rob Hostetter

        Wow, that must have sucked.

    • http://my.opera.com/rafaelluik Rafael

      Wow where are the HTC haters from HTC One drop test now?

    • http://twitter.com/k_norak NK412

      If you spend $400+ for a phone, you pay for the look. Therefore, a case is stupid.

    • http://twitter.com/k_norak NK412

      The bigger the phone, the more breakable it is. The most durable phones are not smart phones.

    • Liz Meiklejohn

      I’ve dropped my s2 about 30 times and it hasn’t cracked once. Once I dropped it down the stairs and it just kept rollin and rollin down, but its never had worse than a few nicks and scratches. But I’ve seen iPhones smashed after one drop.

    Popular

    Latest