The Chromebook Pixel project: Chrome OS

March 8, 2013

    Google Chrome

    Perhaps the most misunderstood part of a Chromebook is the operating system. Some don’t even think it’s a proper OS, while some swear by it. It definitely has limitations, but Chrome OS is probably a lot different than you’ve heard. Let’s get into some truths about Chrome OS, shall we?

    What Chrome OS is

    The central part of any computer is the operating system, and Chrome OS is just not the typical offering. It has a lot going for it, which is rarely discussed. Chrome OS may be a fairly new concept, but it’s not a bad one by any means. In some cases, it may be just what you’re looking for.

    Lightweight

    When your operating system is based on the browser, there’s not much you need on top of it. This is, perhaps, the central point of confusion about Chrome OS. Rather than design and build an entirely new OS to combat Microsoft or Apple, Google went a different route. With the world increasingly moving towards being online almost constantly, Chrome OS makes a lot of sense for many due to it being straightforward and effective for what they want to do.

    Chrome Security

    Secure

    Chrome, be it browser or operating system, is about as secure as you’ll find. A recent hackathon aimed at Chrome OS garnered no viable security breaches, which is rare. Chrome is sandboxed, meaning each tab in the browser operates as a separate function. If one tab is compromised, the nefarious bug is relegated to that tab, and is halted immediately. The likelihood of any virus infecting a computer or network is unlikely, at best.

    This is where having a lightweight OS comes in handy. If an OS is based around the browser, and that browser is inherently secure, your concerns about safety are mitigated. You’re on the web, concerned about safety… and Chrome is central to both.

    Cloud based

    You’ve heard all the arguments about it before, and it’s true… Chrome OS is cloud based. To make good use of Chrome OS, we should understand that cloud based is not cloud reliant. There is local storage on a Chromebook, so you’re able to avoid the cloud if you like. If you need more storage, an external hard drive works well. The operating system makes good use of cloud based services and storage to make your information available anywhere, on any device, but it’s not mandatory.

    Sometimes, referencing a document doesn’t need a big computer screen… a phone or tablet will do just fine. This is the purpose of cloud storage, to have our stuff available anywhere we go, and is something all of us should be comfortable with by now. Google Drive storage is secure, and accessing it on your Android device is really simple.

    Hack Prize Chrome

    What Chrome OS isn’t

    Nothing is perfect, and Chrome OS is far from it. Admittedly, it’s still a work in progress for Google, but still pretty good for what it is. Some glaring omissions are present, but may have a silver lining to them.

    The OS you’re used to

    When you get a Chromebook, there is one glaring omission that screams at you: there is no optical drive. That’s right, there is no way to load software from a CD or DVD. For some, this is a deal breaker, but that’s just the nature of Chrome OS. With such a lightweight layer on top of the browser, there is no bulk for software to make a home.

    Applications take the place of software, making the Chrome Web Store your go-to source for all your needs. Some of us need software that can’t be duplicated or mimicked, so Chrome OS won’t make sense in those instances. Others may find a suitable alternative on the Web Store, perhaps one they like more than their current offering.

    Time consuming

    With a 10 second boot, there is no grand entrance. Chrome OS is up and running in quick order, ready to work or play. All updates are fed to the device over the air, and the device updates every 6 weeks or so. You are rarely even aware of the updates, a stark difference to a traditional PC which can take up to an hour updating itself. Being lightweight has its benefits!

    google_drive

    Productivity and offline usability

    One of the first things you’ll hear about Chrome OS, or Chromebooks in general, is “it’s only a web browser” or “it’s useless without an internet connection”. That has a touch of truth to it, but that’s not the whole picture. If you look at the “competition”, you’ll find they’re making their own push to be web-based. We have to wonder… is Chrome OS ahead of the curve?

    Productivity

    We’ll be getting into this much more next week (spoiler alert!), but Chrome OS is definitely a viable option for productivity. Google drive is a really stellar productivity option, and has a full gamut of services. If that doesn’t suit you, and you still are in need for Microsoft Office, there is Office 365. While Office 365 will cost you handsomely, all Google services are free, including Drive.

    With so many companies switching to Google for their enterprise solutions, we have to consider that Chrome OS is a very realistic option. Whereas Microsoft once ruled the business sector, Google is making a strong push. Their recent purchase of QuickOffice promises to be a real boon for Chrome.

    steam-android-app

    Software and Games

    Some software simply can’t be duplicated with a web app. In those rare instances, Chrome OS isn’t for you. The same goes for PC gaming… right now, Chrome OS just doesn’t support that type of activity. Photoshop has an online option, photoshop express (which also has an Android app), but it’s not the full suite. Gaming is also migrating to the web ever so slightly, so in a few years time this won’t be a concern for most.

    If Chrome OS has an achilles heel, this is it. Developers have been slow to develop for Chrome OS, and a lot of that has to do with varying opinions and trends with coding language. As the Chromebook Pixel becomes a tool more developers pick up, we can expect more tools to be coming to Chrome OS. Some immediate needs or wants aren’t met right now, and that’s to be expected with a fairly new OS like Chrome. A day will come where all of our needs are web-centric, but that day is definitely not today.

    Need versus want

    Can a Chromebook be used offline? Most think not, but they’d be wrong. There is an entire suite of offline apps Chrome OS makes use of. You can create a Google Drive document offline (I wrote this whole article offline to prove it to myself), and there are quite a few games available.

    Let’s also be honest about our internet connection and how they relate to our computers. Setting aside the OS argument, when was the last time you considered a computer useful without an internet connection? If we’re being truthful, most of us will admit we don’t think computers in general have much use when offline. What would we use them for without a connection? Create a document, maybe a presentation… play a few games. All that can be done within Chrome OS.

    Chrome OS is better with a web connection, but it’s not mandatory. For most people, offline productivity won’t change. If a web connection is something you can’t live without, there is always a 3G or LTE version (Pixel only) of the Chromebook available. It may require a different method of accomplishing things, like using Drive rather than MS Office, but that could end up being beneficial.

    Chromebook devices-selector-home-pixel

    Conclusion

    Chrome OS isn’t for everyone, and that’s alright. What everyone should do is consider their needs, and what they want out of a computer. While Chrome OS is a lot like the Chrome browser, it’s not identical. In a weird way, what you give up with Chrome OS can be more valuable than what you get with other operating systems. If you’re looking for a device in which the OS almost disappears, a Chromebook is something you should consider. If you live in the cloud, there is really no reason you should feel the need to wade through a clunky OS to get there.

    If you still have some software needs Chrome OS can’t satiate, perhaps using Linux as an aside is a good option. Many are using the Chromebook Pixel to dualboot Linux, opening up a realm of possibilities. If you’re comfortable with Linux, this is definitely worth a shot. The video below is courtesy of GigaOM (just forgive that he keeps referring to Chrome OS by another name!), which showcases how dualbooting can have some wonderful benefits.

    The debatable factors are always going to be there, but which OS is the best option lies solely with you. As the one using the device, you’ll be the one who needs to see value in it. Do yourself a favor, and take an honest, objective look at your needs and wants. If a Chromebook sounds like a good option, pick one up. If you have a set of needs that isn’t met with Chrome OS, there are plenty of options for you. The only thing you owe yourself is to consider Chrome OS an option.

    Source

    Tags

    Comments

    • Sea ttletech

      Nate I’m sorry that you got personally offended because I didnt agree with your chromebook pixel article. I read most of what you wrote on your google+ site. I find it unprofessional for a journalist to bash their readers. Just to let you know. I am not a samsung fanboy. I live breathe and make a living off technology. So I am very passionate about where technology is headed. I have financial interests in many tech companies so I do analyze where the market is heading. I type with many grammatical errors and run on sentences because I can. I’m not a journalist. I thought this was interesting “Torvalds added that the display is so nice that “suspect I’ll make this
      my primary laptop. I tend to like my laptops slightly smaller, but I
      think I can lug around this 1.5kg monster despite feeling fairly
      strongly that a laptop should weigh 1kg or less.” Why compromise on
      weight? “Because the screen really is that nice.”

      So the creator of linux has the same qualms about the chromebook as i had. I find that you are Chrome OS fanboy and you have some deep rooted hate for

      • Nate Swanner

        It seems as though you’ve got some things you’d like to discuss with me. I suggest you get hold of me on Google+, or email me at nate.swanner@androidauthority.com
        Thanks.

    • V-Phuc

      As a scientist, I often have to make figures out of my scientific data which is in many cases under the form of X-Ray film scans. A software I tended to use in the past is Macromedia FreeHand. Now I’m learning to use IDraw on my MacBook Pro. The ChromeBook and its OS look appealing to me. However, can you suggest a Chrome-based software similar to those I listed (FreeHand and iDraw). Otherwise, I may have to wait a little longer before swiching to Chrome.

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ian-Ray/30902884 Ian Ray

        V-phuc, I use Lucidchart (best for my purposes) and Creately. These are more specialized than Freehand or iDraw, so may not exactly fit your purposes. There is also Inkscape at RollApp.

        • V-Phuc

          Thanks Ian for the software suggestions. It looks like Inkscape resembles the most to Illustrator, FreeHand or iDraw. I don’t make many charts but will keep in mind the 2 other suggestions. Another question related to price and upgrade for these cloud-based softwares, has anyone truly evaluated if it’s more, less, or about the same as if you buy the software the old-fashioned way? I’d be interested to hear some opinions on that issue.

    • William Benn

      Good article. Thank-you. I really enjoy my 11.6 ARM Samsung Chromebook. So much so, I bought another one for my wife a week later. My enjoyment of the Chromebook comes from knowing what I use a computer for and knowing that a Chromebook can accomplish better than 90% of those things. The other 10% I still have my old laptop sitting around.

      • Lowry Brooks

        Just wondering, is browsing pretty fast? I mean, without the overhead of Windows or a full blown OS, is it speedy?

        • William Benn

          I feel they easily keep up with my sons i5 2.4 for basic browsing. Too many tabs though and the i5 pulls away. Probably because he has 8 gigs and we have 2 gigs of RAM.

          • Lowry Brooks

            Nice.

          • Lowry Brooks

            I have a quesion, I tried Chrome OS on virtual Box and the mouse was very slow.(Non trackpad, usb mouse) Have you tried a regular mouse with it? Is it laggy like mine was?

            • Nate Swanner

              Lowry, I have used several mice with the Pixel (but I actually prefer not to use them now that i’m comfortable with keyboard shortcuts). I noticed on the Samsung ARM Chromebook the mouse support was a little jerky. You can adjust that in settings (there is a setting for the mouse), but I also found adjusting the pointer speed helped out.

        • Nate Swanner

          I find the browser to be much snappier on the Chromebooks. In coming from a Windows environment, I attribute the speed increase to the lack of background stuff running fro the OS, meaning the RAM has one job to do on your Chromebook… not Chrome plus a bunch of Windows stuff.

      • Nate Swanner

        William, you’re a good case of someone who properly understands their tech. Thank you for the compliment on the article!

    • tBs_Battousai

      I’ve just bought the Acer C7 and I’ve found that almost overnight it’s replaced my laptop and I don’t think that I’ll be going back to a windows based laptop again, my desktop on the other hand, i think it’ll be a few years before ChromeOS will be be able to replace that but I have no doubts that it could one day…

    • pbekkum

      I have had the chrome book since the cr-48 and live it. Once you get use to working in the cloud, you’ll never go back. Having an OS that pretty much disappears in the background is great. I especially love the constant background updates that improve the OS every 6 weeks is fantastic. If there is something I need to get done that I need an app for, I just go to the Chrome Web store and add it to my apps. It may not be perfect, but it is constantly improving.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/3CP7YLSR3353PAD4XNWKHHU27I Adam

      Your statement “Chrome OS isn’t for everyone, and that’s alright” really hits the nail on the head. Too many analysts criticize the Chromebook for what it can’t do, instead of acknowledging that it meets the needs of certain types of users. And that potential user base will continue to grow.

      The integration with Quickoffice can help make Chromebooks more attractive to business customers, but it may not be enough. Microsoft Office applications are not the only Windows applications out there in the enterprise. Other Windows-based software such as ERP, CRM and even internally developed applications need to be accessed as well.

      Chromebook users that want to work with Windows applications beyond Microsoft Office can use existing solutions such as Ericom AccessNow. AccessNow is an HTML5 RDP client that enables Chromebook users to connect to Terminal Server or VDI virtual desktops, and run any Windows application (not just MS Office) or even full desktops in a browser tab.

      Click here for a live interactive demo:
      http://www.ericom.com/demo_AccessNow.asp?URL_ID=708

      Please note that I work for Ericom

    Popular

    Latest