Apple Hits HTC Anew with Fresh Infringement Case

July 13, 2011
1 18 6 6

    With its lackluster patent portfolio backing it against infringement suits, Taiwan-based original equipment manufacturer HTC is a sitting duck for legal bullets, arrows, and other awfully sharp legal objects. The latest bullet to hit HTC was a patent infringement complaint lodged by Apple against the popular Android device manufacturer. If the ITC rules in favor of Apple, the decision will result in the complete cessation of sales of the infringing devices in the United States.

    Apple filed a complaint last week with the U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC) alleging that HTC infringed 5 patents that Apple owns. Three of the patents-in-suit were also used by Apple in its federal-court lawsuit against Samsung.

    Apple’s ITC complaint against HTC is the latter’s second punch from Apple. The first complaint, involving over ten Apple patents, was hurled by Apple against HTC in March last year.

    Florian Mueller of the FOSS Patents blog lists the following patents as the object of Apple’s complaint versus HTC:

    1. U.S. Patent No. 7,844,915 on “application programming interfaces for scrolling operations” (Apple is asserting this one against Samsung in a federal lawsuit)
    2. U.S. Patent No. 7,469,381 on “list scrolling and document translation, scaling, and rotation on a touch-screen display” (Apple asserts this one in its federal lawsuit against Samsung and, very importantly, in its motion for a preliminary injunction)
    3. U.S. Patent No. 7,084,859 on “programmable tactile touch screen displays and man-machine interfaces for improved vehicle instrumentation and telematics” (not previously asserted)
    4. U.S. Patent No. 7,920,129 on a “double-sided touch-sensitive panel with shield and drive combined layer” (asserted against Samsung in Apple’s first amended complaint in its federal lawsuit)
    5. U.S. Patent No. 6,956,564 on “portable computers” (not previously asserted; Apple acquired this one from British Telecom in 2008)

    The infringement accusation from Apple is targeted at HTC’s Android-based smartphones and tablet:

    • HTC Droid Incredible
    • HTC Droid Incredible 2
    • HTC Wildfire
    • HTC T-Mobile mytouch 3G
    • HTC T-Mobile myTouch 3G Slide
    • HTC T-Mobile G1
    • HTC T-Mobile G2
    • HTC Evo 4G
    • HTC Aria
    • HTC Desire
    • HtC Hero
    • HTC Merge
    • HTC Inspire 4G
    • HTC Evo Shift 4G
    • HTC Thunderbolt
    • HTC Thunderbolt 4G
    • HTC Flyer

    This latest suit brings the total count of Android-related lawsuits to 48, according to Mueller.

    Meanwhile, HTC doesn’t appear cowered. Dismayed that “Apple has resorted to competition in the courts rather than the market place,” HTC will continue to “vehemently deny all of Apple’s past and present claims against it and will continue to protect and defend its own intellectual property as it has already done this year,” said HTC general counsel Grace Lei.

    Apple seems to be carrying a big legal stick and going after many rivals. Do you think it’s really just about protecting its intellectual property? Or is it about Android (in whole or in part)? Or is it about something else?

    Image credit: Polina Sergeeva (Flickr)

    1 18 6

    Comments

    • MrT246007

      I think it’s about Android, and Apple is just to scared to go after Google. Apple is so stupid.

    • Anonymous

      I’m starting to think that Apple “The company” is really getting scared that Android devices are over taking the market with better performing devices and achieving more in getting people converted/connected. It’s starting to look like they are very scared of something. Changes is inevitable

    • ComPuDiZzaL

      While I agree with the Masses. I was hesitant at first to change over from Microsoft phones. But I was so frustrated with slow performance and constant reset’s. My son told me to try Android. I thought it was just a social thing for those under 25 years old. But to my amazement its totally oposite. Android turned out to be just as buying a Harley.. (after 1 week of ownership… no two Android phones are alike) As I do own 4 Apple pc products.. they’re phone’s never drew me in.. due to the over cost of them. Come on.. how can you justify carrying around a 600.00 phone that could just as easy be picked up as yo ball point pen!!! neVAAAA!!! Android sold me on it’s base (Linux) come on can anyone tell what’s negative about Linux… I cant hear you….. I will continue to purchase overly fully functional ANDROID DEVICES TO ITS END…. screw em all.. go android..

    • nwp1953

      I agree with HTC (and probably Samsung also) sentiments that Apple needs to compete in the market place with better products NOT in the court room with lawsuits. These lawsuits only drive up prices but that don’t result in better products. Apple didn’t invent the laptop…why doesn’t someone sue THEM for copying that technology. It is all so very stupid.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002270997143 John Does

      all those patent’s are frivolous, those idea’s were introduced in books and Comic books long before those company’s ever even “though them up”…the patent office needs revamped to change the way it works.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_HLLDBEMBCKKYCZSOD4VCBMSBMY Et

      This is why software patent must go this is absurb which dim witted idiot allowed patents to be transferable. The damned patent was first and formost put in to place to protect the inventors not tobe used for this nonsense. Apple did not create any of this features.

      sign this Petition and put an end to this software patent nonsense.

      https://wwws.whitehouse.gov/petitions/!/petition/direct-patent-office-cease-issuing-software-patents/vvNslSTq?utm_source=wh.gov&utm_medium=shorturl&utm_campaign=shorturl

    Popular

    Latest